Butterfly vs. Round Shield: What's the Difference?
The main difference between the Natursutten Butterfly Shield Pacifier and the Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier is the shield shape, which affects how the pacifier fits against your baby's face. Both are made from 100% pure, all-natural rubber and feature a seamless, one-piece design that prevents bacteria buildup. They also come in the same size ranges and nipple styles, so your choice comes down to which shield your baby prefers.
Shield Shape and Breathing
The butterfly shield has a cut-out top that creates more room for your baby's nose, which can be helpful if your baby has a small nose or tends to push the pacifier. The round shield is designed to gently touch your baby's nose, simulating the feeling of breastfeeding. Both are safe, but the butterfly shield offers a bit more breathing space.
- Butterfly Shield: The cut-out top gives the shield a butterfly shape and makes more room for baby's nose.
- Round Shield: By gently touching baby's nose, the round shield is designed to closely simulate breastfeeding, providing a more familiar soothing experience.
Nipple Style Options
Both the butterfly and round shield pacifiers are available with either a round nipple or an orthodontic nipple. The round nipple mimics the shape and size of a nipple and is best suited for breastfed babies. The orthodontic nipple has a flat bottom and rounded top to reduce pressure on the teeth and gums as baby grows. You can choose the nipple style that works best for your baby, regardless of shield shape.
- Round Nipple: Mimics the shape and size of a nipple, best suited for breastfed babies.
- Orthodontic Nipple: Flat bottom and rounded top reduces pressure on the teeth and gums as baby grows.
Key Product Details at a Glance
-
Natursutten Butterfly Shield Pacifier (Set of Two): Made from 100% pure, all-natural rubber from the Hevea Brasiliense tree. Hand-crafted in Italy. One-piece design prevents bacteria buildup. Butterfly shield offers more nose room; available in round or orthodontic nipple and sizes from 0-6 months to 12+ months.
Natursutten Butterfly Shield Pacifier (Set of Two)
-
Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier (Set of Two): Made from 100% pure, all-natural rubber from the Hevea Brasiliense tree. Hand-crafted in Italy. One-piece design prevents bacteria buildup. Round shield gently touches baby's nose to mimic breastfeeding; available in round or orthodontic nipple and sizes from 0-6 months to 12+ months.
Natursutten Round Shield Pacifier (Set of Two)
Size and Age Ranges
Both the butterfly and round shield pacifiers come in three sizes: Small (0-6 months), Medium (6-12 months), and Large (12+ months). Each set includes two pacifiers of the same size and nipple style. When choosing a size, match it to your baby's age range for the best fit and safety.
Care and Replacement
Both models share the same care instructions. Replace every 6-8 weeks for optimal safety and hygiene. The one-piece design means no crevices for bacteria to hide, making cleaning simpler than standard pacifiers with separate parts.




