Quick answer
Choose the Oh Buoy 2N1 if your day involves water, swimming, or repeated quick-dry cycles. Choose the Caddie if you need a versatile, unlined short for golf, active days, and all-day wear where a stay-tucked waistband matters.
Liner vs. no liner: the biggest practical split
The Oh Buoy 2N1 includes an integrated DropTemp Cooling Hydro Liner and BallPark Pouch, so you get support and cooling built in without separate underwear. The Caddie is unlined, which means you pair it with your preferred SAXX underwear and get a lighter, more breathable short for dry land.
This is the first decision point: if you want one short that handles swimming and lounging without extra layers, the Oh Buoy wins. If you prefer to control your base layer or run hot on the course, the unlined Caddie is the more flexible choice.
Fabric and drying: water versus motion
The Oh Buoy uses a 4-way stretch shell with a quick-dry liner, which suits repeated splashes and drying between swims. The Caddie uses high-performance 4-way stretch fabric without a liner, aimed at full range of motion for golf swings and active days.
Neither short is a dedicated performance garment beyond what the catalog states, so match the fabric to your primary activity rather than expecting one short to do both at a high level.
Waistband and fit details that change the choice
The Caddie features a stay-tucked waistband designed to secure your SAXX apparel styles in place, which helps when you are bending, twisting, or layering. The Oh Buoy does not list that feature, so if waistband security during movement is a priority, the Caddie has the edge.
Both shorts are sized by waist, but the catalog does not list inseam lengths or fit descriptions beyond the fabric notes. If you are between sizes or prefer a specific length, check the size chart before ordering rather than assuming a fit.
Price and value trade-off
At catalog prices, the Oh Buoy 2N1 is USD 46.90 (compared with USD 70.00) and the Caddie is USD 49.77 (compared with USD 79.00). The Caddie costs slightly more at the current price, but it is also the more versatile unlined short for everyday active wear.
If you need a swim short, the Oh Buoy is the more specialized tool and the lower current price makes it an easy add. If you want one short for golf and casual days, the Caddie's stay-tucked waistband and unlined design justify the small difference.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Water use: The Oh Buoy 2N1 is designed as a swim short with a quick-dry liner; the Caddie is unlined and not described as swimwear. Pick Oh Buoy for pools, beaches, or boat days. If your day includes swimming, the liner and quick-dry build are worth it.
- Golf and active motion: The Caddie's stay-tucked waistband and unlined 4-way stretch fabric suit golf swings and all-day movement. The Oh Buoy has a liner that may feel like extra bulk on the course. For golf-first use, the Caddie's waistband security and unlined feel are the practical choice.
- Layering and underwear preference: The Caddie is unlined, so you wear your own SAXX underwear underneath. The Oh Buoy has a built-in liner and pouch, so you do not need separate underwear. Choose based on whether you want a built-in base layer or your own.
Product facts
-
Oh Buoy 2N1: Swim short with a 4-way stretch shell, integrated BallPark Pouch, and DropTemp Cooling Hydro Liner. Built-in support and cooling make it a one-piece solution for swim and beach days.
Oh Buoy 2N1
-
Caddie: Unlined short with a stay-tucked waistband and high-performance 4-way stretch fabric. The unlined design lets you choose your underwear, while the waistband keeps your shirt or base layer in place during activity.
Caddie
Who should buy which
Best for
- Swimmers and beach-goers who want a liner and cooling pouch in one short
- Golfers and active men who prefer an unlined short with a stay-tucked waistband
Not for
- Golfers who want a dedicated unlined short (choose Caddie)
- Swimmers who need a quick-dry liner (choose Oh Buoy 2N1)
