Two expansions, two different jobs
Pagan: Fate of Roanoke already gives you a tense game of hidden roles and accusation. If you are looking for more, Capstone Games offers two ways to expand: the first full expansion, Beyond the Palisades, and the smaller Until Proven Guilty Content Pack #6. They are not competing products – they serve different needs. This comparison helps you decide which one fits your next game night.
What each product actually adds
-
Pagan: Beyond the Palisades: Beyond the Palisades is the first expansion for Pagan: Fate of Roanoke. It introduces two new mechanics: Gloom and Cleanse. It includes 2 new decks for the Witch and Hunter, a new set of Villagers, and 4 new Scenarios. This is a substantial expansion that changes how the game plays, not just adds cards. The Gloom/Cleanse dynamic gives both sides fresh strategic options.
Pagan: Beyond the Palisades
-
Pagan: Until Proven Guilty - Content Pack #6: The Until Proven Guilty Content Pack #6 contains 32 new cards that focus on the social fabric of the colony. It is an expansion for Pagan: Fate of Roanoke. This is a smaller, focused card pack that deepens the social deduction and accusation elements without altering core rules.
Pagan: Until Proven Guilty - Content Pack #6
Beyond the Palisades vs Content Pack #6 at a glance
The table below highlights the main differences to help you see which expansion aligns with your play style.
- Scope: Beyond the Palisades is a full expansion with new mechanics, decks, and scenarios. Content Pack #6 is a card pack that adds 32 cards to the base game.
- New mechanics: Beyond the Palisades introduces Gloom and Cleanse. Content Pack #6 does not add new mechanics; it focuses on social cards.
- Replayability: Beyond the Palisades adds 4 scenarios and two new decks, significantly increasing variety. Content Pack #6 adds 32 cards that can be mixed into existing games.
- Price: Beyond the Palisades is priced at USD 21.26 (catalog comparison price USD 29.95). Content Pack #6 is USD 9.57 (catalog comparison price USD 14.95).
When to start with Beyond the Palisades
If you have played Pagan: Fate of Roanoke several times and want a bigger shift in strategy, Beyond the Palisades is the right choice. The Gloom and Cleanse mechanics change how the Witch and Hunter interact, and the four new scenarios give you structured ways to explore those changes. At about USD 21, it offers the most new content for your money.
When Content Pack #6 makes sense
If you enjoy the social deduction and accusation aspects of the base game and want more of that without learning new rules, Until Proven Guilty Content Pack #6 is a natural fit. The 32 cards focus on the social fabric of the colony, so they slot into your existing games seamlessly. At about USD 9.50, it is an easy way to freshen up the base game without a big investment.
Can you use both together?
Yes. The catalog notes that new Content Packs for Beyond the Palisades are available, including Content Pack #6. This suggests they are designed to be compatible. If you eventually buy Beyond the Palisades, Content Pack #6 can add even more social cards to that expanded game.
What the catalog does not settle
Neither product record specifies a recommended player count, age rating, or play time. These details are not confirmed by the supplied information. If you need to know whether an expansion fits your group size or session length, check the base game box or the publisher's website.

