Two Beard Balms, Two Distinct Scent Profiles
If you're choosing between Pharaoh Beard Balm and All American Beard Balm, the biggest difference is the scent experience. Both balms share the same base formula of high quality oils, butters, and beeswax, so the hold and conditioning are similar. The choice comes down to which aroma fits your style.
Pharaoh Beard Balm features Egyptian Sandalwood sourced from the bark of the Santalum Album tree. According to Beard Care Club, this wood retains its fragrance for decades, giving the balm a rich, woodsy scent that leans cologne-like but more natural. Pharaoh is scented with Egyptian Sandalwood.
All American Beard Balm is a tribute to the 82nd Airborne, developed by co-owner Donny who served with that unit. The scent blends Saffron, Amberwood, Fir Tree Resin, and Cedar, creating a woodsy profile that can fit either the earthy or cologne category. Fans of other Donny-favorite scents like The Norsemen or Heathen will likely enjoy this one.
Key Product Details at a Glance
-
Pharaoh Beard Balm: Pharaoh Beard Balm contains high quality oils, butters, and beeswax to seal in moisture while giving your beard the hold you desire. The balm is smooth, not gritty, and offers the right amount of oils to avoid a greasy look. This confirms Pharaoh provides a medium hold that tames and finishes your beard without excess shine or residue.
Pharaoh Beard Balm
-
All American Beard Balm: All American Beard Balm contains high quality oils, butters, and beeswax to seal in moisture while giving your beard the hold you desire. The balm is smooth and offers the right amount of oils so your beard doesn't look greasy. All American delivers the same type of hold and finish as Pharaoh, making the scent the primary differentiator between the two.
All American Beard Balm
Hold and Texture: What to Expect
Both balms use the same foundational blend of oils, butters, and beeswax, so the hold is comparable. They are designed to tame your beard, give it a finished look, and seal in moisture without making it greasy. The supplied information does not specify a numerical hold strength (e.g., light, medium, strong), so think of them as everyday balms that provide enough hold to shape and control your beard while keeping it soft.
If you are new to beard balm, either product will work the same way: warm a small amount between your palms, work it through your beard, and style as desired. The 2 oz size is the standard option for regular use, and a .25 oz sample is available if you want to test the scent before committing.
Pharaoh vs All American: Side-by-Side
- Scent Notes: Pharaoh: Egyptian Sandalwood — rich, woodsy, cologne-like but natural. All American: Saffron, Amberwood, Fir Tree Resin, Cedar — woodsy, earthy, with a dark edge.
- Inspiration: Pharaoh draws from the sacred Santalum Album tree. All American honors the 82nd Airborne, developed by a veteran of that unit.
- Hold and Feel: Both balms use oils, butters, and beeswax for a smooth, non-greasy hold that tames and finishes the beard. No specific hold level is stated.
- Price: Both are priced at USD 14.25 (catalog comparison price USD 19.00). Pharaoh is USD 13.87 (catalog comparison price USD 19.00). The difference is minimal.
- Available Sizes: Both offer 2 oz Beard Balm Only, 2 oz Beard Balm & 1 oz Beard Oil Combo (Save $5.00), and .25 oz Sample.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Pharaoh Beard Balm if you prefer a single-note sandalwood scent that is rich, warm, and naturally cologne-like. It's a straightforward woodsy choice that works well for daily wear.
Choose All American Beard Balm if you want a more complex woodsy scent with layers of saffron, amber, fir, and cedar. It carries a personal story from the brand's veteran co-owner, making it a meaningful pick for those who appreciate that connection.
If you're still unsure, the .25 oz sample of each is an affordable way to compare them directly before buying the full 2 oz jar.

