The real difference is the curve, not the brand
Both the Pierre Fitch and Allen King dildos come from Fleshjack Boy and are made from platinum cured silicone. The meaningful choice between them comes down to two things: how much insertable length you want and whether a pronounced curve helps or hinders the way you play. The catalog gives you enough to compare those points honestly, but it does not include care instructions or compatibility details for either dildo, so treat this as a shape and size decision rather than a complete usage guide.
Length and girth, side by side
-
Allen King - Dildo: Length from base to tip: 7.25" including balls. Insertable length: 5.5" excluding balls. The shorter insertable length makes the Allen King dildo the easier starting point if you want a size you can use regularly rather than occasionally.
Allen King - Dildo
-
Allen King - Dildo: Circumference at base of shaft: 5.75". A thicker base can feel fuller at the point of entry, so the Allen King dildo trades some length for more girth than the Pierre Fitch.
-
Pierre Fitch - Dildo: Length from base to tip: 8.25" including balls. Insertable length: 6.75" excluding balls. The longer insertable length gives the Pierre Fitch dildo more reach, which matters if depth is part of what you are looking for.
Pierre Fitch - Dildo
-
Pierre Fitch - Dildo: Circumference at base of shaft: 5.5". The Pierre Fitch is slightly slimmer at the base than the Allen King, so the extra length does not come with extra girth.
Why the Allen King curve changes the decision
The catalog describes the Allen King dildo as curving just where you would want it to, and that curve is the main reason to choose it over the longer Pierre Fitch. A curved shaft is most useful when you want targeted pressure rather than straight-line depth. If you already know you prefer a curved toy, the Allen King shape is the more deliberate pick. If you have never used a curved dildo, the shorter 5.5" insertable length makes it a lower-commitment way to find out whether that shape works for you.
The trade-off is reach. The Allen King gives up 1.25" of insertable length compared with the Pierre Fitch, so if your priority is filling depth, the curve will not make up for that difference.
When the Pierre Fitch length is the point
The Pierre Fitch dildo is the choice for people who already know they want more insertable length and do not need a curve to get there. At 6.75" insertable, it sits noticeably longer than the Allen King, and its 5.5" base circumference is slightly slimmer. That combination suits a straight, depth-focused approach more than a targeted one. The catalog does not describe a curve for the Pierre Fitch, so do not assume it has the same shaping as the Allen King.
If you are sizing up from a shorter toy, the Pierre Fitch is the bigger step. The Allen King is the more conservative choice for regular use, which is how the catalog frames it.
Which shape fits your play style
Use these pairings to match the dildo to what you already know you like. They are based only on the supplied length, girth, and curve descriptions.
- Choose Allen King if you want a curved shape for targeted pressure: The catalog specifically describes a curve, and the shorter insertable length makes it easier to use regularly.
- Choose Allen King if you prefer more girth over more length: Its 5.75" base circumference is thicker than the Pierre Fitch's 5.5", while its insertable length is shorter.
- Choose Pierre Fitch if depth is your main goal: The 6.75" insertable length gives you 1.25" more reach than the Allen King, with a slightly slimmer base.
- Choose Pierre Fitch if you want a straight, no-fuss profile: The catalog does not describe a curve for this dildo, so it is the simpler shape if you are not looking for targeted pressure.
What the catalog does not settle for you
Neither product record includes cleaning instructions, lubricant compatibility, or suction-base details. That means you should not assume either dildo has a suction base or that a particular lubricant is recommended. Platinum cured silicone is the one material fact the catalog confirms for both, and that is the safest basis for comparing them. If you need confirmed care steps before buying, check the full product page or packaging rather than relying on this comparison.
The catalog also does not describe the Pierre Fitch as curved, so if curve is your deciding factor, the Allen King is the only one of the two with that shape confirmed in the supplied information.