Quick answer
For full-game coverage in one purchase, Pillars of Fate Sleeves are the clear choice with 105 sleeves; Mythic Mischief Sleeves cover one volume per pack, so you need two packs for both volumes.
Coverage and pack size trade-off
The biggest difference comes down to how many sleeves you get and what they cover. Pillars of Fate Sleeves include 105 clear sleeves, enough to protect every card in Pillars of Fate, including the Community Cards. That means one pack handles the whole game.
Mythic Mischief Sleeves include 33 sleeves, sized to cover all cards in either Mythic Mischief Vol. I or Vol. II. If you own both volumes, you will need two packs to protect everything. That is an important consideration if you want uniform protection across your collection.
Fit and sizing consistency
Both products use standard poker-size sleeves (63.5 x 88.9 mm), so the physical fit is the same. If you already sleeve other games with poker-size sleeves, these will feel familiar and shuffle consistently.
The transparent design on both lets you keep the original card artwork visible. If you play with cards that have unique backs or artwork, clear sleeves preserve that look while adding protection.
How to choose
- For Pillars of Fate owners: Choose Pillars of Fate Sleeves for a one-and-done purchase. The 105-sleeve pack covers every card in the game, including Community Cards, so you won't need to track down extras.
- For Mythic Mischief owners: If you only have one volume, a single pack of Mythic Mischief Sleeves is enough. If you have both Vol. I and Vol. II, plan to buy two packs to protect every card. Check which volumes you own before ordering to avoid a second shipping round.
- For mixed collections: Since both use standard poker-size sleeves, you can mix them across different games. But note the pack-size difference: 105 vs 33 sleeves changes how many packs you need per game. Count your cards first. For a standard 100-card deck, Pillars of Fate Sleeves cover it; Mythic Mischief Sleeves would require three packs.
Product facts
-
Pillars of Fate Sleeves: Includes 105 clear sleeves sized at poker dimensions (63.5 x 88.9 mm) to cover every card in Pillars of Fate, including Community Cards. One pack provides complete protection for the entire game, so you don't need to buy extra sleeves later.
Pillars of Fate Sleeves
-
Mythic Mischief Sleeves: Includes 33 clear sleeves sized at poker dimensions (63.5 x 88.9 mm) to cover all cards in Mythic Mischief Vol. I or Vol. II. If you own both volumes, you'll need two packs to protect your full collection, which affects your total cost.
Mythic Mischief Sleeves
Which sleeves fit your game night?
Best for
- Pillars of Fate players who want full-game protection in a single purchase
- Mythic Mischief players who own only one volume and want a budget-friendly sleeve option
Not for
- Mythic Mischief players who own both volumes and expect one pack to cover the entire collection