Two Loafers, Two Leather Personalities
Choosing between the Beaumont Loafers in pull-up leather and the Hudson Loafer in nubuck is really a question of how you want your shoes to look, feel, and age. Both are casual leather loafers from Beckett Simonon, but their materials lead to different strengths in comfort, durability, and style versatility. This guide compares what the catalog confirms about each so you can decide which fits your routine.
What Each Loafer Brings to the Table
-
Beaumont Loafers - Pull-Up - Men's: The Beaumont Loafers are made from robust pull-up leather sourced from a Gold-Rated tannery based in Arzignano, Italy. Pull-up leather is known for developing a rich patina over time. The Gold rating from the Leather Working Group indicates a strong environmental commitment, which may matter to you if sustainability is a priority.
Beaumont Loafers - Pull-Up - Men's
-
Hudson Loafer - Nubuck - Men´s: The Hudson Loafer features velvety nubuck leather, a lightweight EVA sole, and multi-layer construction for flexibility and cushioning. Nubuck offers a soft, suede-like feel but requires more careful maintenance. The EVA sole and multi-layer build suggest all-day comfort, making this a good choice if you're on your feet a lot.
Hudson Loafer - Nubuck - Men´s
Material and Care: Pull-Up vs Nubuck
The most important difference between these loafers is the upper material. Pull-up leather is aniline-dyed and infused with oils, giving it a natural two-tone effect that deepens with wear. It's relatively low-maintenance—occasional conditioning preserves the patina. Nubuck is buffed cowhide with a soft, velvety nap; it's more vulnerable to water and stains and needs a protective spray and regular brushing. If you prefer a shoe that develops character with minimal fuss, pull-up leather suits you. If you're willing to invest a bit more care for a plush feel, nubuck is rewarding.
- Beaumont Loafers (Pull-Up): Robust, develops patina, Gold-Rated Italian tannery. Lower maintenance.
- Hudson Loafer (Nubuck): Velvety soft, requires protective sprays and brushing. Higher maintenance.
Comfort and Construction Details
- Hudson Loafer - Nubuck - Men´s: The Hudson Loafer has a lightweight, resilient EVA sole and multi-layer construction that enhances flexibility and cushioning. If you walk a lot or stand for long periods, the Hudson's construction aims for all-day support. The catalog specifically highlights flexibility and cushioning, which is not claimed for the Beaumont.
- Beaumont Loafers - Pull-Up - Men's: The Beaumont Loafers feature stunning solid brass ornamentation and a distinct, dynamic appearance. The brass ornament gives the Beaumont a more statement-making look. The catalog describes them as 'statement loafers,' so they lean toward a bolder aesthetic compared to the Hudson's refined simplicity.
Style Versatility: Understated vs Statement
The Hudson Loafer is described as a 'wardrobe essential' that blends sophistication with casual versatility. Its sleek upper and subtle detailing make it easy to pair with chinos, jeans, or even tailored trousers. The Beaumont Loafers, with their distinct shape and solid brass ornament, are more of a conversation piece. The catalog notes they look particularly attractive with casual clothing but can also work with relaxed chinos and some suits. If you want one loafer that disappears into any outfit, choose the Hudson. If you want your footwear to stand out, the Beaumont is the pick.
Sizing and Fit: What You Can and Cannot Confirm
Both loafers are available in sizes 7–14, but the catalog does not include specific fit guidance like width, arch support, or whether they run true to size. The Hudson Loafer's multi-layer construction may affect fit differently than the Beaumont's pull-up leather, which can stretch slightly with wear. Without more detailed sizing data, your best bet is to rely on Beckett Simonon's standard size chart and consider your typical loafer size. If you're between sizes, the lack of half sizes beyond 10.5 (the Hudson offers 7, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10, 10.5, 11, 11.5, 12, 13, 14) means you may need to size up or down.
The Verdict: Which Loafer Fits Your Routine?
Choose the Beaumont Loafers if you want a low-maintenance leather that develops character over time, and you're comfortable with a bolder, ornamented look. The pull-up leather from a Gold-Rated tannery is a durable, environmentally conscious choice. Choose the Hudson Loafer if you prioritize all-day cushioning and a soft, refined upper that works with almost anything, and you're willing to care for nubuck. Neither is objectively better—they serve different preferences in material feel, care commitment, and style statement.

