Two Raiding Games, Two Different Experiences
Garphill Games has built a reputation for thoughtful worker-placement games set in the Viking age. Two of their most popular titles, Raiders of the North Sea and Raiders of Scythia, share a core premise of raiding settlements for victory points, but they differ in how you prepare, score, and end the game. This comparison highlights the key differences so you can choose the one that fits your group's tastes.
How You Prepare for Raids
Both games require you to assemble a crew and gather supplies before raiding, but the specific actions differ.
- Raiders of the North Sea: You place a worker in one of eight village buildings to perform an action, then pick up a different worker from another building. Before raiding, you must build your crew size and collect provisions. Raiding a settlement also requires a worker of the right color, and for monasteries and fortresses, you need gold as well.
- Raiders of Scythia: You also need to assemble a crew and gather provisions, but you must train Animals as an additional preparation step. This adds a new resource to manage and a different strategic layer before you can set out on a raid.
Scoring Victory Points
In both games, victory points (VPs) are your main goal, but the ways to earn them shift between the two titles.
How You Earn Victory Points
- Raiders of the North Sea: VPs come primarily from raiding settlements, taking plunder, and making offerings to the Chieftain. How you use your plunder is also vital. Additional scoring comes from military strength and Valkyries, which also bring grey and white workers into the game.
- Raiders of Scythia: VPs are gained by raiding settlements, taking plunder, and completing Quests. Quests replace offerings as a distinct scoring path, giving you an alternative route to points beyond raiding alone.
End-Game Conditions
The game ends under different triggers, which affects how long a session lasts and when you need to pivot your strategy.
When the Game Ends
- Raiders of the North Sea: The game ends when only one fortress raid remains, all Valkyrie have been removed, or all offerings have been made. After that, players tally their scores.
- Raiders of Scythia: The game ends when only 2 unraided settlements or 2 quests remain on the main board. This gives a slightly different pacing and may lead to a shorter or longer game depending on player choices.
Product Details at a Glance
-
Raiders of the North Sea: Raiders of the North Sea: To raid a settlement you need a large enough crew, enough provisions (plus gold for monasteries/fortresses), and a worker of the right color. VPs come from raiding, plunder, and offerings. Understanding the specific requirements helps you plan your turns and manage resources efficiently.
Raiders of the North Sea
-
Raiders of Scythia: Raiders of Scythia: Players need to assemble a crew, train animals, and gather provisions. VPs are gained by raiding settlements, taking plunder, and completing quests. The addition of animal training and quests changes the strategic focus and gives you more ways to score.
Raiders of Scythia
Which One Should You Choose?
If you prefer a classic worker-placement loop with a tight resource puzzle around crew, provisions, and worker colors, Raiders of the North Sea delivers a polished experience. If you want a fresh twist with animal training and quest-based scoring, Raiders of Scythia offers new strategic depth. Both games reward careful planning and efficient turns, but the different end-game conditions and scoring paths give each a distinct feel.

