The two Red Boy plugs are not sized the way you might expect
The Red Boy Medium and Red Boy Large are both phthalate-free body safe material plugs from the same line, but their catalog measurements do not scale in a simple small-to-big line. The Medium is listed at 5" in usable length and girth, while the Large is listed at 4.5" in length with a 7" girth. That means the Large is shorter in length but substantially wider, and the catalog ties each size to a different experience level: the Medium to intermediate users and the Large to more advanced players.
What the catalog confirms about each size
-
Red Boy - Butt Plug - Medium: The Medium version is 5" in usable length and girth and is described as perfect for intermediate users. This gives you the Medium's full listed measurement and the experience level the catalog assigns to it.
Red Boy - Butt Plug - Medium
-
Red Boy - Butt Plug - Large: The Large version is 4.5" in length with a 7" girth and is described as perfect for the more advanced player. This shows the Large's shorter length and much wider girth, plus the advanced experience level the catalog assigns.
Red Boy - Butt Plug - Large
Medium vs Large at a glance
The table below uses only the measurements and experience levels stated in the supplied catalog records. It does not add estimates for diameter, weight or material firmness.
- Red Boy Medium (product 755345): 5" usable length and girth; catalog describes it as perfect for intermediate users; phthalate-free body safe material.
- Red Boy Large (product 755356): 4.5" length and 7" girth; catalog describes it as perfect for the more advanced player; phthalate-free body safe material.
- The key difference: The Large is 0.5" shorter in listed length but 2" larger in listed girth, so the jump between sizes is mainly a width decision, not a length decision.
Why girth matters more than length here
If you are comparing these two because you want the next step up, look at the girth figure first. The Medium's 5" usable length and girth and the Large's 7" girth are the clearest differences the catalog provides, and the Large's shorter 4.5" length means you are not adding length by moving up. The catalog's own experience labels point the same way: intermediate for the Medium, more advanced for the Large.
That makes the Medium the more conservative choice if you are moving beyond a starter plug, and the Large a deliberate step for someone who already knows they want more width. The supplied records do not include a diameter, so use the listed girth as the comparison point rather than converting it to a width you have not confirmed.
How to choose between the two
- Choose the Medium if you are stepping up from a smaller plug: The catalog labels it for intermediate users and lists 5" usable length and girth, making it the gentler of the two jumps.
- Choose the Large if width is the goal and you are already experienced: The catalog labels it for more advanced players and lists a 7" girth, which is the main reason to pick it over the Medium.
- Do not choose the Large for extra length: Its listed length is 4.5", which is shorter than the Medium's 5" usable length, so length is not the reason to size up.
- Check the material claim on both: Both are listed as made from phthalate-free body safe material, so material is not a deciding difference between the two.
What the supplied information does not settle
The supplied records do not include care instructions, lubricant compatibility guidance, a diameter measurement, a weight, or a firmness rating for either plug. They also do not give a recommended progression schedule or a rule for how long to spend at one size. Treat those as open questions rather than assuming a detail the catalog has not confirmed. If you need those specifics before buying, the honest position is that this comparison can tell you the listed length, girth, material claim and stated experience level, and nothing more.

