Three Saybrook Sandals, One Shared Build

The Saybrook family gives you the same criss-cross leather strap design and prong-free Italian buckle in three distinct finishes: Cognac, Rose Gold and Platinum. All three use soft leather straps, a leather insole and a cushioned rubber sole, so the main decision comes down to color and available sizes. The Cognac Saybrook II is the only one with an explicit fit note in the product record, which makes it the easiest starting point if you are unsure about sizing.

Below, compare what each color offers and how to match it to your child’s wardrobe and your size needs.

Color and Size at a Glance

  • Cognac Saybrook II Sandal: Warm cognac leather. Sizes 3, 4 and 5. Fit note: size up one size compared to FP baby shoes, runs true to size compared to regular shoes, and size up if in between sizes.
  • Rose Gold Saybrook Sandal: Rose gold metallic finish. Sizes 3, 4, 5 and 6. No fit note in the supplied record.
  • Platinum Saybrook Sandal: Platinum metallic finish. Sizes 3, 5 and 6 (no size 4 in the supplied variant list). No fit note in the supplied record.

Cognac: The Grounded, Everyday Choice

Cognac is the most traditional of the three and pairs easily with denim, neutrals and summer prints. The Saybrook II record includes a clear sizing instruction: size up one size compared to Freshly Picked baby shoes, but it runs true to size compared to regular shoes. If your child is between sizes, go up. This note is specific to the Cognac Saybrook II and is not repeated for the metallic finishes, so treat it as your baseline for the Saybrook style and check the other colors with that in mind.

Cognac Saybrook II: Fit and Construction

  • Cognac Saybrook II Sandal: Genuine leather straps and insole with a custom cushioned rubber outsole. These materials match the other Saybrook colors, so the Cognac’s main differentiator is its documented sizing guidance.

    Cognac Saybrook II Sandal

    Cognac Saybrook II Sandal

  • Cognac Saybrook II Sandal: Fit note: size up one size compared to FP baby shoes; runs true to size compared to regular shoes; size up if in between sizes. This is the only Saybrook record with explicit sizing advice, making it the safest reference when ordering any Saybrook sandal.

Rose Gold and Platinum: Metallic Finishes with a Size Difference

Rose Gold and Platinum bring a dressier look. Both share the same prong-free buckle and cushioned sole as the Cognac, but their size runs differ in the supplied records. Rose Gold is listed in sizes 3, 4, 5 and 6, while Platinum is listed in 3, 5 and 6—size 4 is not shown for Platinum. If your child wears a size 4, Rose Gold is the metallic option available in that size. Neither metallic record includes a fit note, so use the Cognac guidance as a starting point and consider your child’s usual shoe size.

Rose Gold and Platinum: What the Records Confirm

  • Rose Gold Saybrook Sandal: Rose Gold Saybrook Sandal is available in sizes 3, 4, 5 and 6. This is the only metallic Saybrook that includes size 4 in the supplied variant list.

    Rose Gold Saybrook Sandal

    Rose Gold Saybrook Sandal

  • Platinum Saybrook Sandal: Platinum Saybrook Sandal is available in sizes 3, 5 and 6. Size 4 is not listed, so Platinum may not work if your child is in that size.

How to Choose Your Saybrook Color

  • Start with size availability: If your child wears size 4, Rose Gold is the only metallic option listed; Cognac also comes in 4. Platinum skips size 4 in the supplied record.
  • Match the finish to the outfit: Cognac is a warm neutral for everyday wear; Rose Gold and Platinum are metallic accents for dressed-up looks.
  • Use the Cognac fit note as your guide: The Cognac Saybrook II record says to size up one size compared to FP baby shoes and to size up if between sizes. Apply that logic to the metallic colors too, since no separate fit note is supplied for them.

What the Records Do Not Confirm

The supplied information does not include care instructions for any of the three sandals, so check the packaging or the product page for cleaning guidance. It also does not state whether the metallic finishes are waterproof or how they wear over time. Finally, the Rose Gold and Platinum records do not include a fit note, so the Cognac sizing guidance is the only official fit advice available for the Saybrook style.