Eighteen cards, six shoals, one boat

Shallow Regrets is a wallet game built around a simple fishing loop. The supplied product record describes a set of 18 cards that you lay out as 6 shoals. At least three of those shoals must have a small shadow — the easiest fish to catch — on top. That setup requirement shapes the opening board before anyone takes a turn.

The record also lists a catalog price of USD 9.15 against a comparison price of USD 15.00, and a single Standard variant. If you are weighing a small-box card game for a table that likes light rules and a bit of push-your-luck, this guide walks through the contents, the turn, and the trade-offs the record actually supports.

What the product record confirms

  • Shallow Regrets: Use all 18 cards to create 6 shoals. This is the full component count and the layout the game expects, so you know the box is a compact 18-card set rather than a deck-building pool.

    Shallow Regrets

    Shallow Regrets

  • Shallow Regrets: At least 3 of these must have a small shadow, the easiest fish to catch, on top. The setup rule guarantees some easy catches are available at the start, which matters for new players learning the hook system.

  • Shallow Regrets: Each turn, the active player reels in 2 fish from the shoal(s) of their choice. The turn is short and choice-driven: two fish per turn, drawn from any shoal, keeps downtime low.

How a turn actually plays out

On your turn you reel in 2 fish from the shoal or shoals of your choice. You may keep one of them in your boat; the unkept fish return to the shoals. Keeping a fish is not automatic, though. Each fish has a strength value, and to keep it you must already have enough hooks in your previously caught fish to meet that strength value. That hook requirement is the core tension: early catches build your capacity to land bigger fish later.

Many fish also have otherworldly abilities that affect play. You use an ability by exhausting the fish — turning it sideways to show the ability has been used. Some fish are considered foul, and whoever caught the most foul fish takes a scoring penalty. When all fish have been caught, or no player can catch any of the remaining fish, everyone tallies the total value of their caught fish, and the fisher with the highest total wins.

Who Shallow Regrets fits — and who should look elsewhere

  • New to wallet games: The turn is one action — reel in two fish, keep at most one — and the hook rule is the only real arithmetic. That makes it an approachable entry point for a group that wants a small game with a clear loop.
  • Players who like a light push-your-luck decision: Choosing which shoal to fish from and whether a catch is worth keeping against your current hook count gives each turn a small gamble without long rule explanations.
  • Groups that dislike penalties: The foul-fish scoring penalty is part of the design. If your table prefers pure positive scoring, this is a trade-off to accept going in.
  • Buyers who need a player count or age range: The supplied product record does not list a player count, age range, or play time. Treat those as open questions to confirm before buying rather than assuming a number.

Buying Shallow Regrets vs. adding an expansion

The site's recent Shallow Regrets setup guide covers The Fisher & The Frod expansion. This guide is about the base game itself, so the two serve different decisions.

  • Buy the base game first if: You want the 18-card fishing loop described above and have not yet played Shallow Regrets. The base set is the complete game the turn structure assumes.
  • Consider the expansion after if: You already know the base loop and want to change how a turn works. The expansion guide on this site explains what The Fisher & The Frod adds; the supplied record for the base game does not describe expansion compatibility, so check the expansion listing before mixing.

What to check before you add it to your cart

  • Component count: The record confirms 18 cards. If you expected a larger deck or extra tokens, this is a compact wallet-format set.
  • Setup requirement: At least three shoals need a small shadow on top. That is a rule to follow at setup, not an optional variant.
  • Scoring shape: Highest total value wins, but foul fish can drag your score down. Plan for the penalty rather than ignoring it.
  • Unconfirmed details: Player count, age range, play time, and whether the cards are sleeved or unsleeved are not stated in the supplied information. Ask the store or check the box copy if any of those decide your purchase.