Two JRPGs, Two Different Experiences
If you are deciding between Shin Megami Tensei V: Steelbook Edition on Nintendo Switch and Arc of Alchemist on PlayStation 4, you are looking at two very different approaches to the genre. One is a dark, tactical demon-collecting epic; the other is a lighter, base-building action RPG. Both are available now at approachable prices, but which one fits your mood and hardware better? This comparison uses the supplied catalog facts to help you decide.
What Each Game Offers Out of the Box
-
Shin Megami Tensei V: Steelbook Edition (Nintendo Switch, 2021): Comes with original slipcover in good condition. Steelbook is in excellent condition and is free of dents and significant scratches. The Steelbook Edition adds a collectible metal case and slipcover, making it a physical treat for Switch owners who value packaging.
Shin Megami Tensei V: Steelbook Edition (Nintendo Switch, 2021)
-
Arc of Alchemist (Playstation 4, 2020): Item is brand new in original shrink wrap. Case is free of cracks, dents and creases. Arc of Alchemist is factory-sealed, ideal for collectors who want a pristine PS4 case or plan to keep the game sealed.
Arc of Alchemist (Playstation 4, 2020)
Gameplay and Story: Depth vs. Action
Shin Megami Tensei V revolves around the Press Turn Battle System. You pinpoint enemy weaknesses to earn extra turns, but one wrong move can end the fight. The story is described as an "allusive story filled with tragic choices" where you pursue light or darkness. Recruiting demons through negotiation and fusing them into custom allies is central to progression. This is a challenging, strategic JRPG that rewards planning.
Arc of Alchemist takes a different path. You lead Quinn Bravesford and her squad across a desert to find the Great Power. The Western release adds 7 playable characters, each with unique weapons and abilities. Combat is real-time with elemental orb combinations (fire, water, wind, earth) used for puzzles and combat. You also build and customize a base to strengthen your party. It is a more action-oriented, lighter experience with base-building mechanics.
Shin Megami Tensei V Steelbook vs Arc of Alchemist: Key Differences
- Platform: SMT V Steelbook is for Nintendo Switch. Arc of Alchemist is for PlayStation 4. Choose based on which console you own.
- Gameplay Style: SMT V is turn-based with demon negotiation and fusion. Arc of Alchemist is real-time action with orb puzzles and base building.
- Story Tone: SMT V is a dark, moral tale of sacrifice and choice. Arc of Alchemist is a hopeful desert quest to save humanity.
- Physical Extras: SMT V Steelbook includes a slipcover and steelbook case (some shelf wear on slipcover). Arc of Alchemist is brand new in shrink wrap with a standard case.
- Price: SMT V Steelbook is priced at USD 28.40 (compared to USD 40.00). Arc of Alchemist is USD 16.75 (compared to USD 25.00).
Which One Should You Buy?
Choose Shin Megami Tensei V Steelbook if you own a Switch, enjoy deep tactical combat, and want a collectible steelbook case. The demon fusion and negotiation systems add hours of strategic customization. The lower price compared to its original MSRP makes it a solid value for a premium edition.
Choose Arc of Alchemist if you prefer action RPGs with base building and character swapping. The 7 playable characters and elemental orb puzzles offer variety. At USD 16.75, it is an affordable entry point for PS4 owners who want a lighter, more accessible JRPG.

