Two convertible deck boxes, one clear decision

The Sidekick 100+ XL Convertible and the Squire Plus 100+ XL Convertible both hold a 100-card Commander deck in double sleeves, and both use Gamegenic's convertible lid system that clips to the bottom to save table space. The real differences are the display feature, the outer dimensions, the sleeve fit and the price. This comparison uses only the supplied catalog details so you can match the box to how you actually play.

Capacity and sleeve fit: what each box is built to hold

  • SQUIRE PLUS 100+ XL CONVERTIBLE: Designed to hold up to 100 double-sleeved cards in extra thick Inner Sleeves; also fits 100 regular double-sleeved cards with extra room for token cards. If your Commander deck uses thick inner sleeves, the Squire Plus is explicitly rated for that load without removing tokens.

    SQUIRE PLUS 100+ XL CONVERTIBLE

    SQUIRE PLUS<br><span class="mtg\_headline mtg\_subline">100+ XL CONVERTIBLE</span>

  • SIDEKICK 100+ XL CONVERTIBLE: Made to fit 100 double-sleeved cards in particularly thick Inner Sleeves; holds 100 regular double-sleeved cards and additional tokens, or a Commander deck in thicker inner sleeves. The Sidekick 100+ XL covers the same double-sleeved 100-card use case, so capacity alone does not separate the two boxes.

    SIDEKICK 100+ XL CONVERTIBLE

    SIDEKICK</br><span class="gg\_product\_subline">100+ XL CONVERTIBLE</span>

Dimensions: how much table space each box takes

The Squire Plus 100+ XL measures 85 x 100 x 102 mm (W x D x H). The Sidekick 100+ XL measures 104 x 96 x 78 mm externally, with an inner compartment of 95 x 78 x 69 mm. The Squire Plus is taller and narrower; the Sidekick is wider and lower. If you pack decks side by side in a bag, those footprints matter more than total volume. The Sidekick's inner compartment figures also tell you the usable card space, while the supplied Squire Plus record gives only external size.

Display and access: Slide Card Case vs open-box visibility

  • SQUIRE PLUS 100+ XL CONVERTIBLE: Includes a detachable Slide Card Case with additional UV protection for displaying the Commander or top card; the stored deck can be identified without opening the box, and the protected card can be used during gameplay. Choose the Squire Plus if you want your commander visible on the table and protected between games without opening the deck box.
  • SIDEKICK 100+ XL CONVERTIBLE: Sideloading design with cards stored horizontally; the completely removable cover clips to the bottom, and the open box can be displayed and tilted in a wide variety of ways. Choose the Sidekick if you prefer horizontal card access and flexible tilting during play rather than a dedicated display window.

Sidekick vs Squire Plus at a glance

  • Commander display: Squire Plus includes a detachable Slide Card Case with UV protection; Sidekick has no slide case in the supplied details.
  • Card orientation: Sidekick stores cards horizontally (sideloading); Squire Plus orientation is not specified in the supplied record.
  • Outer size: Squire Plus: 85 x 100 x 102 mm. Sidekick: 104 x 96 x 78 mm, with a 95 x 78 x 69 mm inner compartment.
  • Convertible lid: Both have a completely removable cover that clips to the bottom to save table space.
  • Surface and closure: Squire Plus uses Armorfyber surface with microfiber lining and strong magnets; Sidekick uses Nexofyber surface with microfiber lining and powerful magnets.
  • Catalog price: Squire Plus: USD 23.03 (comparison price USD 31.99). Sidekick: USD 16.24 (comparison price USD 24.99).
  • Color options: Squire Plus: teal-pink, black, blue, red, green, white. Sidekick: teal-pink, yellow, orange, red, pink, purple, blue, green, white, black, sand.

Sleeve compatibility and the fine print

Both product records note that sleeves from other brands may affect capacity or compatibility, and both are optimized for Gamegenic sleeves. The Squire Plus record specifically says it is optimized for Gamegenic Sleeves. Neither box's supplied information confirms fit with every third-party sleeve brand, so test your actual sleeve stack before relying on a tight capacity figure. The Sidekick record also states it is 100% compatible with convertible storage solutions such as the Dungeon, which may matter if you already use that system.

Which one fits your setup?

Pick the Squire Plus 100+ XL Convertible if you want your commander displayed and protected in a slide case, prefer a taller narrower footprint, and do not mind paying more for the display feature. Pick the Sidekick 100+ XL Convertible if you want a lower, wider box with horizontal access, like the idea of tilting the open box during play, and want to save money. Both handle a 100-card double-sleeved Commander deck, so the choice comes down to display preference, dimensions and budget rather than raw capacity.