Two silicone tools, two different freezing jobs
Both products in this comparison freeze food, but they do not produce the same shape or serve the same purpose. The Done by Deer Silicone Ice Pops 3 Pack is a set of three individual moulds designed to be filled, frozen and squeezed, with attached lids. The Mushie Baby Food Freezer Tray is a multi-cup tray where each cup holds 1.5oz/45ml and has markings for measuring.
If you are searching for teething ice pops or ice lolly molds for babies, the ice pop set is the closer match. If you want to freeze homemade baby puree or milk in measured portions, the freezer tray is the closer match. The records do not confirm an age range for either product, so use your own judgement about what and how much you offer your child.
What the Done by Deer ice pop set confirms
-
Done by Deer Silicone Ice Pops 3 Pack - Tiny Farm Blue: The set contains three silicone ice pop moulds with attached lids and a leak-proof design. Attached lids reduce lost pieces, and the leak-proof claim matters if you freeze filled moulds in a busy freezer.
Done by Deer Silicone Ice Pops 3 Pack - Tiny Farm Blue
-
Done by Deer Silicone Ice Pops 3 Pack - Tiny Farm Blue: Each mould is soft, flexible silicone that is easy to fill, freeze and squeeze. The squeeze-to-release design is what makes this an ice pop rather than a portion tray.
-
Done by Deer Silicone Ice Pops 3 Pack - Tiny Farm Blue: The set is dishwasher safe, freezer ready and made from food-grade materials. These are the practical cleaning and storage points to check before buying reusable ice lolly molds for babies.
What the Mushie freezer tray confirms
-
Mushie Baby Food Freezer Tray - Cambridge Blue: Each cup holds 1.5oz/45ml and has markings to take the guesswork out of measuring. Measured cups suit homemade baby puree freezing and portioning milk or food, rather than hand-held licking.
Mushie Baby Food Freezer Tray - Cambridge Blue
-
Mushie Baby Food Freezer Tray - Cambridge Blue: A clip-on lid keeps little meals secure, and frozen foods pop out of the silicone cups with ease. The lid protects stored portions, and easy release matters when you are popping out one cup at a time.
-
Mushie Baby Food Freezer Tray - Cambridge Blue: The tray is described as a food prep essential for storing milk and food for your little one. This confirms its intended role as a storage tray, not a teething ice pop mould.
Silicone ice pops vs freezer tray: side by side
- Shape and use: The Done by Deer set makes individual ice pops that are squeezed from flexible moulds. The Mushie tray makes 45ml cup portions that pop out of silicone cups. One is for holding and licking; the other is for storing and serving measured portions.
- Capacity and measuring: The Mushie tray gives a stated 1.5oz/45ml per cup with markings. The Done by Deer record does not state a capacity per mould, so do not assume a portion size from the listing.
- Lids: Both records mention lids: attached lids on the ice pop moulds and a clip-on lid on the freezer tray. Attached lids stay with the mould; a clip-on tray lid covers all cups at once.
- Cleaning: The Done by Deer set is stated as dishwasher safe. The supplied Mushie record does not confirm dishwasher suitability, so check the manufacturer's care guidance before cleaning it that way.
- Best fit for teething: The ice pop set is the more direct fit for teething ice pops because it is designed to be frozen and squeezed. The freezer tray is better suited to preparing and storing puree or milk portions, which you would then serve separately.
Which one to buy for homemade purees
For homemade baby puree freezing, the Mushie tray's 45ml cups and measuring markings make portion control straightforward. You can freeze puree in the cups, clip the lid on for storage, and pop out a portion when needed. That is a different workflow from filling an ice pop mould, freezing it, and handing it to a child to squeeze.
The ice pop set can still be used for puree-based frozen treats, but the record describes it as an ice pop mould, not a measured storage tray. If you want both a teething option and a portioning option, they complement each other rather than replace each other.
What neither record confirms
Neither supplied record states an age range, so this comparison cannot tell you when a baby is ready for either product. Neither record confirms safe-sleep or car-seat use, and neither should be used for those purposes. The Done by Deer record does not state a capacity per mould, and the Mushie record does not confirm dishwasher suitability.
These gaps are limitations of the supplied information, not proof that the products lack those features. Check the packaging or manufacturer guidance for any detail you need before first use.




