Start with your baby's age, not the cup label
The first decision in the sippy cup vs straw cup question is not which style looks easier. It is which cup matches your baby's current stage. A cup listed for 6+ months and one listed for 12+ months are built for different levels of control, and using the age guidance as your starting filter prevents most of the frustration that comes with an early or late switch.
Both cups in this guide use a straw rather than a spout, so the real comparison is between a soft, lightweight training tumbler and an insulated cup with a more protective leak system. That distinction matters more than the word 'sippy' on the packaging.
What the 6+ month option confirms
-
Infantino My First Tumbler - Mint: Infantino My First Tumbler - Mint is listed for age 6+ months and holds 266 ml (9 oz). The 6+ month starting point makes this the earlier of the two cups, and 266 ml is a manageable portion for a baby still learning to sip.
Infantino My First Tumbler - Mint
-
Infantino My First Tumbler - Mint: It is made from 100% premium silicone and BPA-free materials, with a soft silicone straw tip and an easy-grip handle. Soft materials and a handle suit little hands that are still building grip strength, which is often the real barrier in the first weeks of cup use.
-
Infantino My First Tumbler - Mint: The 2-piece leak-resistant straw system includes a smart valve that controls liquid flow and helps minimise spills when the cup is turned upside down. Leak resistance is described as minimising spills rather than eliminating them, so set expectations for a training phase rather than a fully spill-proof cup.
What the 12+ month option confirms
-
Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ - Assorted: Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ is listed for children aged 12 months and over and holds 266 ml. The 12+ month listing places it a full six months later than the Infantino tumbler, so it suits a child who already has some cup experience.
Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ - Assorted
-
Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ - Assorted: Its insulated body keeps drinks at their ideal temperature for longer, and the listing describes 100% leak-proof INTELLIVALVE technology that prevents leaks even when the cup is turned upside down or shaken. Insulation and a stronger leak claim are the main practical upgrades for toddlers who carry their own cup around and tip it frequently.
-
Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ - Assorted: The BACSHIELD antibacterial straw is paired with a BPA-free construction free from BPS, PVC, phthalates and nitrosamines. Hygiene and material transparency are the priorities this listing emphasises, which matters if the cup will be used repeatedly through the day.
Sippy cup vs straw cup: the trade-offs that actually decide it
Neither cup is better in every situation. Use the differences below to match the cup to your child's stage and your daily routine.
- Age and readiness: The Infantino tumbler starts at 6+ months; the Tommee Tippee cup starts at 12+ months. Choose the cup whose listed age range your baby has reached rather than introducing the later cup early.
- Grip and independence: The Infantino cup emphasises a lightweight, soft design with an easy-grip handle. The Tommee Tippee listing focuses on the straw and leak system rather than a handle, so check how your child prefers to hold a cup.
- Spill tolerance: Infantino describes leak-resistant technology that minimises spills. Tommee Tippee describes 100% leak-proof performance even when shaken or turned upside down. If the cup will travel in a bag or be waved around, the stronger claim is worth weighing.
- Temperature and capacity: Both hold 266 ml, but only the Tommee Tippee cup is described as insulated to keep drinks at temperature for longer. Capacity is therefore not the deciding factor between them.
- Cleaning routine: The Infantino cup can be disassembled and is top-rack dishwasher safe or hand washable. The supplied Tommee Tippee record does not confirm cleaning instructions, so check the packaging before relying on dishwasher use.
When to introduce a straw cup and when to move on
Use the listed age as your guide rather than a deadline. If your baby is around six months and just beginning to handle a cup, the Infantino My First Tumbler is the more appropriate starting point because its soft silicone straw tip and handle are designed for that early learning stage. Its leak-resistant valve also keeps the learning curve manageable at home or on the go.
If your child is already 12 months or older and has some sipping experience, the Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ addresses the next set of needs: insulation for longer outings, a leak-proof claim suited to a toddler who turns the cup upside down, and an antibacterial straw for repeated daily use. Moving to it is a step up in protection, not a correction of the first cup.
What the listings do not settle
Some details you may want are not confirmed in the supplied product information. Treat these as questions to check on the packaging or with the retailer rather than assuming either way.
- Replacement straws: Neither record confirms whether replacement straws or valves are sold separately, which matters for long-term use.
- Tommee Tippee cleaning instructions: The Infantino cup confirms top-rack dishwasher safety and hand washing. The Tommee Tippee record does not confirm cleaning or dishwasher guidance.
- Exact materials for the Tommee Tippee cup body: The listing confirms it is free from BPA, BPS, PVC, phthalates and nitrosamines, but the body material itself is not specified in the supplied information.
- Handle on the Tommee Tippee cup: A handle is not mentioned in the supplied Tommee Tippee details, so do not assume one is included.
A practical way to choose
If your baby is between 6 and 12 months and you want a soft, lightweight first cup with a handle, start with the Infantino My First Tumbler - Mint. If your child is 12 months or older and you need insulation and a stronger leak-proof claim for daily travel, the Tommee Tippee Insulated Straw 266ml 12m+ fits that brief. Many families will use both in sequence, and that is a sensible way to follow the age guidance each cup provides.




