Quick answer

If you want the more distinctive display piece, choose Derek Smalls (None More Black) with his leather harness and black bass. If you prefer a classic frontman look, choose David St. Hubbins (None More Black) with his black rhythm guitar. Both are 3.75-inch scale and work well together.

What separates the two figures

Both figures are inspired by Smell the Glove and share the same dark attire and 3.75-inch scale. The main difference is the character design and the included accessory: Derek Smalls wears his signature leather harness and comes with a black bass, while David St. Hubbins comes with a black rhythm guitar. That makes Derek the more eccentric, scene-stealing figure and David the more straightforward rock frontman.

Scale and display considerations

Both are 3.75-inch scale, so they fit alongside other ReAction Figures and most 3.75-inch collectibles. The None More Black theme means both figures are dressed in dark attire, which can make them blend into a dark shelf. If you display them together, consider a lighter background or subtle lighting to keep the details visible.

Price and value

At the time of writing, Derek Smalls is priced at $12.80 and David St. Hubbins at $12.20, both below their $20.00 comparison prices. The small price difference is unlikely to be the deciding factor; choose based on which character or accessory you prefer.

Decision rules for choosing your Spinal Tap figure

  • If you want the most recognizably Spinal Tap detail: Choose Derek Smalls for the leather harness and bass, which capture the film's eccentric humor.
  • If you prefer a classic frontman look: Choose David St. Hubbins for his dark attire and rhythm guitar, a more traditional rock pose.
  • If you plan to display them together: Buy both to recreate the band's rhythm section, but use a lighter backdrop so the all-black outfits remain visible. Check shelf lighting before committing to a dark display.
  • If budget is the deciding factor: The price difference is small; pick the character you like more rather than the cheaper option.

Product facts

Who should buy which

Best for

  • Spinal Tap fans who want a distinctive, humorous display piece (Derek Smalls)
  • Collectors who prefer a classic frontman figure with a guitar (David St. Hubbins)
  • Anyone building a complete Wave 02 set

Not for

  • Collectors who prefer larger-scale figures with more articulation
  • Fans looking for other band members from the film