Quick Answer

Choose St. James's 1684 if you love a heritage-inspired, floral scent with a charitable story; choose Twenty Nine if you prefer a warm, spicy unisex fragrance for everyday wear.

Heritage vs. Modern Appeal

St. James's 1684 draws inspiration from the reredos in Christopher Wren's St. James's Piccadilly, a masterpiece from 1684. This gives it a classic, church-inspired character that suits those who appreciate tradition and craftsmanship.

Twenty Nine, on the other hand, is a modern unisex line, born from the popular Almond Oil Soap range. Its blend of Rose Geranium, Cinnamon, and Clove creates a distinctive, warm aroma that feels contemporary and versatile.

Your choice ultimately depends on whether you value historical storytelling or everyday wearability.

Scent Profile: Floral vs. Spicy

St. James's 1684 is inspired by the ornate reredos, suggesting a more floral and possibly resinous character, though detailed notes aren't specified. It's a fragrance that evokes a sense of place and history.

Twenty Nine is explicitly described as a warm blend of Rose Geranium, Cinnamon, and Clove. This spicy-floral combination is both distinctive and unusual, making it a bold choice for those who want to stand out.

If you're unsure about a full bottle, consider the price difference: St. James's 1684 is offered at a more accessible price point, making it easier to try.

Occasion and Versatility

St. James's 1684, with its heritage ties, might feel more suited to formal events or when you want a fragrance that sparks conversation about its background.

Twenty Nine's warm, spicy blend is described as 'ideal for use at day'—suggesting it's a reliable choice for daily wear, whether at work or leisure.

Consider your lifestyle: if you want a signature scent for everyday, Twenty Nine's versatility is a strong point. If you prefer a special-occasion fragrance with a story, St. James's 1684 is compelling.

How to Choose: St. James's 1684 vs Twenty Nine

  • Prefer heritage and story: Choose St. James's 1684 for its historical inspiration and charitable partnership. It's a fragrance that carries meaning beyond its scent. If you value a backstory, this is the one.
  • Prefer modern versatility: Choose Twenty Nine for its warm, spicy blend that's designed for daywear. It's a safe bet for regular use and unisex appeal. For daily wear, Twenty Nine is the practical pick.
  • Budget consideration: St. James's 1684 is priced lower than Twenty Nine, making it an easier entry point if you're trying a new fragrance or want a gift. If cost is a factor, start with St. James's 1684.

Product Facts

  • St. James's 1684 Eau de Toilette - D R Harris London: St. James's 1684 is a collaboration with St James's Church, Piccadilly, raising money for The Wren Project and inspired by the reredos in Christopher Wren's 1684 masterpiece. Wearing it connects you to a charitable cause and a piece of London's architectural history, making it more than just a scent.

    St. James's 1684 Eau de Toilette - D R Harris London

    St. James's 1684 Eau de Toilette - D R Harris London

  • Twenty Nine Eau de Toilette: Twenty Nine is fragranced with Rose Geranium, Cinnamon, and Clove, creating a warm blend that is ideal for daytime use. This spicy-floral combination offers a distinctive, unisex aroma that performs well in daily settings, from office to casual outings.

    Twenty Nine Eau de Toilette

    Twenty Nine Eau de Toilette

Which Fragrance Fits You?

Best for

  • St. James's 1684: history enthusiasts and those who enjoy floral scents with a charitable mission
  • Twenty Nine: individuals seeking a warm, spicy unisex fragrance for everyday wear

Not for

  • St. James's 1684: those who prefer bold, spicy scents or need a fragrance for daily high-energy activities
  • Twenty Nine: those who dislike cinnamon or clove notes, or who want a fragrance with a strong heritage narrative