Quick answer

Choose the Starling 20 for a classic, polished penny loafer with a wearable 20mm outsole, or the Starfinch 15 for a pointed, Parisian-chic silhouette with a slimmer profile.

Silhouette and style

The Starling 20 is a reimagined smoking slipper with a tailored penny loafer shape. It’s a classic, polished prep style that works on or off the clock.

The Starfinch 15 is the pointed-toe version of the Starling. Its slim silhouette and pointed toe offer a modern, feminine twist, described as the epitome of Parisian chic.

Comfort and outsole height

Both loafers feature Birdies’ signature 7 layers of cloud-like comfort and rubber pods in the front soles for extra tread.

The Starling 20 has a 20mm classic-looking outsole, giving it a slightly more substantial feel. The Starfinch 15, with its lower profile, is designed for a sleeker look.

Key trade-offs

  • Toe shape: The Starling 20 has a classic rounded toe (penny loafer). The Starfinch 15 has a pointed toe.
  • Outsole height: The Starling 20 has a 20mm outsole. The Starfinch 15 has a lower profile (15mm). If you prefer a slightly taller sole for more cushioning, choose the Starling 20.
  • Style vibe: The Starling 20 is polished prep. The Starfinch 15 is Parisian chic and feminine.

Product facts

  • The Starling 20 Loafer - Burgundy Velvet: The Starling 20 features a 20mm outsole and a hand-stitched interior for maximum flexibility. This gives the Starling 20 a more substantial feel underfoot while maintaining flexibility, ideal for all-day wear.

    The Starling 20 Loafer - Burgundy Velvet

    The Starling 20 Loafer - Burgundy Velvet

  • The Starfinch 15 Embroidery - Ocean Velvet: The Starfinch 15 is a pointed-toe version of the Starling, featuring a slim silhouette and reverse embroidery. The pointed toe creates a more elongated, dressy look that pairs well with tailored pants or skirts.

    The Starfinch 15 Embroidery - Ocean Velvet

    The Starfinch 15 Embroidery - Ocean Velvet

Which loafer fits your style?

Best for

  • Those who want a classic, versatile penny loafer that works with jeans or office wear
  • Anyone who prefers a rounded toe and a slightly more substantial sole

Not for

  • Those who want a pointed, dressier silhouette
  • Anyone seeking the lowest-profile loafer