Quick answer

Choose The Starling 20 if you want a more cushioned, slip-resistant loafer with a chunkier 20mm outsole. Choose The New Starling if you prefer a slimmer, more feminine toe and a lighter feel.

What changed in the silhouette

The New Starling features a resculpted, slimmer toe that creates a more elongated and feminine look. The original Starling keeps the classic penny loafer shape that has made it a bestseller. If you prefer a sleek, dressier profile, the New Starling delivers that; if you want the timeless silhouette, stick with the original.

Comfort and outsole differences

Both shoes share the signature 7 layers of cloud-like comfort, so the underfoot cushioning is consistent. The Starling 20 adds a wearable 20mm outsole with rubber pods in the front soles for slip resistance, making it a more practical everyday option. The New Starling has a defined heel and a lighter construction, which may appeal if you prioritize a closer-to-the-ground feel.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Classic silhouette vs. modern slimmer toe: The Starling 20 keeps the original penny loafer shape. The New Starling narrows the toe for a more elongated, feminine line. Choose based on your preferred profile.
  • Chunkier outsole vs. lighter feel: The Starling 20 has a 20mm outsole with rubber pods for slip resistance. The New Starling has a defined heel and a lighter construction. If you need extra grip, go with the 20; if you want a closer-to-the-ground feel, pick the New Starling. Consider your daily surfaces: the 20's rubber pods are a clear advantage on slick floors.
  • Price difference: The Starling 20 is priced at USD 123.00 (compare at USD 205.00) while the New Starling is USD 106.75 (compare at USD 175.00). The 20 costs a bit more for the added outsole features. If budget is tight, the New Starling offers the same cloud comfort at a lower price.

Product facts

  • The Starling 20 - Leopard Print Haircalf: The Starling 20 features a 20mm outsole, rubber pods in the front soles for slip resistance, and a stitched interior for flexibility. This makes it a more stable, all-weather choice for commutes or long days on your feet.

    The Starling 20 - Leopard Print Haircalf

    The Starling 20 - Leopard Print Haircalf

  • The Starling - New Leopard Print Haircalf: The New Starling has a resculpted, slimmer toe for a more feminine and elongated look, with a defined heel and the same 7-layer comfort. The sleeker toe creates a dressier, more refined profile that pairs well with tailored outfits.

    The Starling - New Leopard Print Haircalf

    The Starling - New Leopard Print Haircalf

Which one fits you?

Best for

  • The Starling 20: commuters and all-day wearers who want slip resistance and extra cushioning
  • The New Starling: those who prefer a sleeker, more feminine toe and a lighter feel

Not for

  • The Starling 20: if you want a slim, dressy silhouette or a lighter shoe
  • The New Starling: if you need maximum slip resistance or a thicker outsole