Quick answer
Start with Stella and Chewy's Frozen Chicken Dinner Patties for a lower-cost, cage-free poultry option, switch to Super Beef if you want grass-fed red meat, and choose Dandy Lamb when your dog needs a novel protein or you prefer lamb. All three are complete and balanced 95% meat, organ, and bone patties, so the real decision is protein preference, price, and what your dog tolerates.
What separates the three recipes
The recipes share a similar frame: each is a frozen raw dinner patty made in the USA with 95% meat, nutrient-rich organs, and bone, and each is pea-free, lentil-free, and potato-free with organic fruits and vegetables. The difference is the animal protein: cage-free chicken, grass-fed beef, or grass-fed lamb. That matters most for dogs with protein sensitivities or picky palates, and for households watching the grocery budget.
Because the catalog does not list guaranteed analysis, calorie content, or patty count per 6 lb bag, you cannot compare them on protein percentage or cost per meal from this page alone. Use the bag label for those numbers and treat the prices below as a starting point, not a full nutrition comparison.
Price and value trade-offs
At catalog prices, the chicken patties are the least expensive at USD 33.49 (compared with USD 49.99), the beef patties are USD 40.14 (compared with USD 54.99), and the lamb patties are USD 32.99 (compared with USD 54.99). That makes lamb the lowest-priced option in this set despite being a red-meat protein, while beef carries the highest price. If cost per bag is your main filter, chicken and lamb are the closer call, and beef is the premium pick.
Price per bag is not price per meal. Without calorie or patty-count data, you cannot assume a 6 lb bag lasts the same number of days across recipes. Weigh your dog's portions on a kitchen scale and track how long a bag actually lasts before deciding which recipe is the better value for your household.
When a novel protein is the deciding factor
If your dog has done well on chicken but you suspect a poultry sensitivity, lamb is the common next step because it is a different protein source. Beef is another option, but it is not automatically more novel than chicken for every dog. The honest limitation is that none of these recipes is hypoallergenic by formulation, and the catalog does not supply elimination-diet guarantees. If you are working through a suspected allergy, confirm the choice with your veterinarian rather than switching recipes on price alone.
Trade-offs to weigh before you buy
- Chicken: lowest-risk everyday pick: Choose chicken if your dog has no history of poultry issues and you want the lowest upfront cost among the poultry and beef options. Trade-off: it is the least novel protein here, so it is a poor starting point if you are deliberately rotating away from chicken. Check the bag label for feeding amounts, since portion guidance is not supplied in the catalog.
- Beef: red meat at a premium: Choose beef if your dog does well on red meat and you want a grass-fed beef recipe. Trade-off: it costs more per bag than chicken or lamb at catalog price, so confirm your dog likes beef before committing to a 6 lb bag.
- Lamb: novel protein without the highest price: Choose lamb if you want a non-poultry protein and the lowest catalog price in this set. Trade-off: lamb is still a red meat, so it is not a guaranteed solution for every sensitive dog; introduce it slowly and watch for changes. Transition over several days by mixing a small amount with your dog's current food.
The three patties at a glance
-
Stella and Chewy's Frozen Chicken Dinner Patties 6 LB: Frozen raw patties made with 95% cage-free chicken, organs, and bone, pea-free, lentil-free, and potato-free. A poultry-based complete dinner that suits dogs already doing well on chicken and budget-conscious households.
Stella and Chewy's Frozen Chicken Dinner Patties 6 LB
-
Stella and Chewy's Frozen Super Beef Dinner Patties 6 LB: Frozen raw patties made with 95% grass-fed beef, organs, and bone, pea-free, lentil-free, and potato-free. The red-meat choice for dogs that prefer beef, at the highest catalog price of the three.
Stella and Chewy's Frozen Super Beef Dinner Patties 6 LB
-
Stella and Chewy's Frozen Dandy Lamb Dinner Patties 6 LB: Frozen raw patties made with 95% grass-fed lamb, organs, and bone, pea-free, lentil-free, and potato-free. A lamb-based option for dogs that need a different protein, priced lowest in this set at catalog.
Which recipe fits your dog
Best for
- Dogs already eating chicken successfully and owners who want the lowest-cost poultry patty
- Dogs that prefer beef and owners who want a grass-fed red-meat dinner
- Dogs that need a lamb-based protein or owners comparing lamb against poultry
Not for
- Dogs with a diagnosed poultry allergy should skip the chicken recipe
- Dogs on a veterinarian-prescribed elimination diet should not switch recipes without veterinary guidance
- Owners who need guaranteed analysis or calorie data before buying should check the bag label or ask the store first


