The short answer: pick by how you smoke and where it sits

The Stinky Cigar Ashtray and the Single Cigar Metal Ashtray both give you a dedicated place to rest a cigar, but they solve different problems. The Stinky is a smaller-taller design with a deep bowl and stainless steel stirrups, built for someone who wants a stable, heavy ashtray that holds its ground outdoors. The Single Metal Ashtray is a sleek, affordable single-cigar rest for a lounge or smoker's area, and the catalog even suggests buying two.

If you smoke on a patio and want one ashtray that stays put and handles ash from a full session, the Stinky's dimensions and materials are the stronger match. If you want a simple, low-cost rest for one cigar at a time, the Single Metal Ashtray is the practical pick.

Size, material, and capacity at a glance

  • Stinky Cigar Ashtray: 6½ inches tall by 7 inches diameter; bowl holds the same volume as the original Stinky; bowl and base are malleable iron with a hot-electrostatic powder-coated finish; each cigar stirrup has a polished stainless steel useable surface.
  • Single Cigar Metal Ashtray: Sleek metal look; described as an affordable option for your lounge and a perfect addition to any smoker's area. The supplied record does not list dimensions, bowl capacity, or specific metal type.

What the Stinky Cigar Ashtray record confirms

  • Stinky Cigar Ashtray: This new 'smaller-taller' Stinky Cigar Ashtray is 6½ inches tall by 7 inches diameter. The taller, narrower footprint makes it a stable, space-conscious choice for a patio table or balcony ledge.

    Stinky Cigar Ashtray

    Stinky Cigar Ashtray

  • Stinky Cigar Ashtray: The bowl holds the same volume as the original Stinky Cigar Ashtray. If you liked the original's capacity but wanted a smaller footprint, this version keeps the deep bowl without taking up more table space.

  • Stinky Cigar Ashtray: The useable surface of each cigar stirrup is still polished stainless steel. Stainless steel stirrups are a practical detail for resting a lit cigar without worrying about the finish on the rest itself.

What the Single Cigar Metal Ashtray record confirms

  • Single Cigar Metal Ashtray: If sharing an ashtray isn't for you and you dig the sleek, metal look...look no further! The product is explicitly positioned for solo smokers who want a clean metal look, so it fits a one-cigar-at-a-time routine.

    Single Cigar Metal Ashtray

    Single Cigar Metal Ashtray

  • Single Cigar Metal Ashtray: You have found an affordable option for your lounge. Price is a real differentiator here; the Single Metal Ashtray is the lower-cost way to add a dedicated rest to a lounge or smoker's area.

  • Single Cigar Metal Ashtray: These are priced to move and the perfect addition to any smoker's area...you should just go ahead and get two before they're gone! The catalog itself suggests buying two, which makes sense if you want separate rests for different spots rather than sharing one.

Where the evidence stops: what you cannot compare

The supplied records are not symmetrical. The Stinky entry gives you exact height, diameter, bowl volume, and materials, so you can judge its footprint and heft before buying. The Single Metal Ashtray entry gives you positioning and price context but no dimensions, bowl capacity, or metal specification. That means you cannot compare the two ashtrays inch for inch or ounce for ounce from the available information.

This gap matters most if you are choosing for a windy patio or a small side table. The Stinky's 7-inch diameter and 6½-inch height are known; the Single Metal Ashtray's footprint is not confirmed by the supplied information. If exact size is critical, the Stinky is the safer bet because its dimensions are documented. If you are flexible on size and want a simple single-cigar rest, the Single Metal Ashtray's lack of listed dimensions is less of an obstacle.

Price and value: what the numbers say

At the catalog prices shown, the Stinky Cigar Ashtray is USD 23.09 (comparison price USD 34.99) and the Single Cigar Metal Ashtray is USD 24.47 (comparison price USD 35.99). The two are close in price, so the decision is less about saving a dollar and more about which design suits your smoking setup.

The Stinky gives you documented dimensions, a deep bowl, and a heavy malleable-iron base with a powder-coated finish. The Single Metal Ashtray gives you a sleek metal look and a solo-smoker focus, and the catalog suggests buying two. If you want one ashtray that does the job for a full session on a patio, the Stinky's known specs justify its price. If you want a pair of simple rests for a lounge or multiple spots, two Single Metal Ashtrays cost a little more than one Stinky but give you two separate places to rest a cigar.

How to choose without overthinking it

  • Choose the Stinky Cigar Ashtray if:: You smoke on a patio or balcony and want a stable, heavy ashtray with a deep bowl, documented dimensions, and stainless steel stirrups. The 6½-inch height and 7-inch diameter let you plan its spot before it arrives.
  • Choose the Single Cigar Metal Ashtray if:: You want an affordable, sleek metal rest for one cigar at a time, especially for a lounge or smoker's area. The catalog suggests buying two, which suits separate seating spots.
  • Choose neither if:: You need confirmed bowl capacity or exact dimensions from the Single Metal Ashtray record, or you need care and safety instructions for either product. Those details are not in the supplied information, so check the product pages or contact the store before ordering.