Two Lemon Black Teas, Two Personalities

If you're looking for a citrusy black tea, Clipper Ship Tea Company offers two lemon-forward options: Sunshine Lemon and Lemon Palmer. Both start with brisk Ceylon black tea and lemon, but their flavor profiles, availability, and best uses differ. This comparison helps you choose based on what matters most to you.

Flavor and Ingredient Differences

The key difference is sweetness versus bold citrus. Sunshine Lemon leans sweet with vanilla, while Lemon Palmer is a straightforward, tangy lemon tea with fruit undertones.

  • Sunshine Lemon: Tasting notes: sweet lemon and hints of vanilla. Ingredients: black tea, lemon myrtle, lemon peel, vanilla. The vanilla rounds out the lemon, making it feel brighter and softer.
  • Lemon Palmer: Tasting notes: sweet lemon, brisk black tea. Ingredients: black tea, lemon, lemon peel, freeze dried lemon, pineapple, apple, red currants. The fruit adds complexity without overwhelming the lemon, creating a bolder, more citrus-forward cup.

What the Catalog Confirms

  • Sunshine Lemon: Sunshine Lemon is available only in summer. Tasting notes: sweet lemon and hints of vanilla. Ingredients: black tea, lemon myrtle, lemon peel, vanilla. If you want a tea with a limited seasonal window and a creamy-sweet vanilla finish, this is the one.

    Sunshine Lemon

    Sunshine Lemon

  • Lemon Palmer: Lemon Palmer is a blend of brisk Ceylon black tea with bold lemon. Tasting notes: sweet lemon, brisk black tea. Ingredients include pineapple, apple, and red currants. This tea is available year-round and offers a fruitier, more complex lemon flavor without vanilla. It's also described as perfect for flash chilling or cold brew.

    Lemon Palmer

    Lemon Palmer

Brewing and Serving

Both teas share the same steep directions: use 1 heaping teaspoon per 8 oz of boiling water (205-212°F) for 3-4 minutes. They both work well hot or iced. Sunshine Lemon is described as excellent hot and iced, with a happy, soothing character. Lemon Palmer is specifically recommended for flash chilling or cold brew to make a refreshing iced tea, leaning into its half-and-half lemonade inspiration.

If you plan to brew iced tea often, Lemon Palmer's fruit and lemon notes hold up well to chilling. Sunshine Lemon's vanilla sweetness also shines iced, but its limited summer availability means you'll want to stock up.

Which One Fits Your Routine?

Choose Sunshine Lemon if you enjoy a sweet, vanilla-accented lemon tea and don't mind that it's only sold in summer. It's a treat best enjoyed during warm months, and you can buy larger sizes to last through the year.

Choose Lemon Palmer if you want a year-round, bold lemon tea with fruit complexity. It's more versatile for iced tea methods and doesn't rely on vanilla, making it a straightforward citrus black tea for any season.

Both are available in Small (50g), Medium (150g), Large (300g), and XL (454g) sizes, so you can sample before committing to a larger tin.