Two Taggies soft toys, two distinct sensory experiences
The Taggies Camilla Caterpillar Soft Toy by Mary Meyer and the Soft Toy Taggie Giraffe 'Tilly' both belong to the Taggies family, known for satin ribbons that babies love to touch. But they differ in shape, colour palette, and how they are introduced. This comparison breaks down what each toy offers so you can pick the one that fits your baby's preferences and your family's needs.
Camilla Caterpillar: soft colours and taggie ribbons
-
Taggies Camilla Caterpillar Soft Toy by Mary Meyer: Crafted from the softest materials, Camilla showcases beautiful soft shades of pink, coral, and soft greens. The gentle colour palette may appeal to parents looking for a visually calming toy, while the soft fabric suggests a plush feel for cuddling.
Taggies Camilla Caterpillar Soft Toy by Mary Meyer
-
Taggies Camilla Caterpillar Soft Toy by Mary Meyer: With Taggies ribbons adding an extra sensory experience, Camilla is designed to engage and delight babies as they explore. The ribbons provide tactile stimulation, which is the core appeal of the Taggies line.
Tilly Giraffe: a guided introduction to Taggies
-
Soft Toy Taggie Giraffe 'Tilly': Introduce a child to the Taggies strategy. Start by rubbing their backs and shoulders with a satin taggies ribbon. They will be mesmerized, snuggling into that silky loop to discover its secrets. This toy comes with a suggested introduction method, which can help parents who are new to Taggies engage their baby gently.
Soft Toy Taggie Giraffe 'Tilly'
-
Soft Toy Taggie Giraffe 'Tilly': Then move onto more stimulating activities like shaking, pulling and chewing! The toy is designed to support a progression from calming touch to active play, which may suit babies who enjoy varied sensory input.
-
Soft Toy Taggie Giraffe 'Tilly': Taggies was born over a decade ago when a mom noticed her child’s fascination with satin tags. This idea blossomed into a world of treasured products. The brand story reinforces the focus on satin tags as the central feature, which is consistent across both toys.
Key differences at a glance
- Design and colours: Camilla is a caterpillar in soft pink, coral, and green shades. Tilly is a giraffe, though the supplied information does not specify its colours.
- Sensory focus: Both feature Taggies ribbons. Tilly's description explicitly mentions rubbing, shaking, pulling, and chewing, while Camilla's focuses on exploration and delight.
- Introduction guidance: Tilly comes with a step-by-step suggestion for introducing the toy, starting with a calming ribbon rub. Camilla's description does not include a specific method.
- Price: Camilla is listed at USD 17.22 (compared to USD 24.95), and Tilly at USD 20.37 (compared to USD 29.95). Both are currently discounted.
Which toy suits your baby?
If you prefer a toy with a clear, guided introduction that moves from calming to active play, Tilly Giraffe provides that structure. Its description outlines a specific sequence: rub with the ribbon, then encourage shaking, pulling, and chewing. This can be helpful if you want ideas for how to engage a young baby with a new sensory toy.
If you are drawn to a soft, colourful companion without a prescribed method, Camilla Caterpillar offers a plush caterpillar in gentle hues. The emphasis is on exploration and the sensory appeal of the ribbons, leaving the type of play open-ended. This may suit babies who are already familiar with Taggies or parents who prefer to let their baby lead the interaction.
What the listings leave open
Neither product record includes a specific age range, material composition, or care instructions. The supplied information also does not confirm whether either toy is suitable for newborns or has been tested for teething. If these details are important to you, check the product packaging or contact the retailer before purchase. Both toys are listed as standard variants with no additional options.

