Quick Answer

If you have almond or round eyes and want a wispy, textured look that adds soft definition, choose The Bestie. If you have hooded or monolid eyes and prefer a more lifted, open-eyed effect, Aster is the better pick—though it's not in the current lineup, so consider The Flirt as a dramatic alternative.

Choosing between The Bestie and Aster for your DIY lash extensions comes down to your eye shape and the finish you want. Both styles are popular for at-home application, but they differ in texture, length variation, and overall effect. Understanding these differences helps you avoid the frustration of lashes that don't flatter your natural features.

In this comparison, we'll break down what each style offers, who they suit best, and the tradeoffs you should know before adding them to your cart. Whether you're new to lash clusters or a seasoned pro, this guide will help you make a confident choice.

The Bestie: Wispy Texture with Soft Definition

The Bestie is an elevated, wispy lash style known for its gentle spikes and subtle length variation. It features a softly tapered inner corner that adds texture without overpowering your natural look. This makes it a great next step if you already love The Sweetheart® or Shorties® and want something with a bit more dimension.

Because of its wispy design, The Bestie works well on almond and round eyes. The tapered inner corner helps elongate the eye, while the gentle spikes create a feathered, natural finish. It's a versatile style that can be dressed up or down, making it a solid everyday choice.

Aster: A Dramatic Alternative for Lifted Eyes

Aster is not currently available in the FlutterHabit lineup, but it's often sought after for its dramatic, eye-opening effect. While we can't confirm its exact specs, styles like The Flirt offer a similar bold lift and curl that can replace a full set of extensions. If you're looking for more drama and a pronounced cat-eye, The Flirt is a reliable substitute.

For hooded or monolid eyes, a dramatic curl and volume can help create the illusion of a lifted lid. The Flirt's bold lift and eye-opening curl make it a strong contender for those who want to open up their eye shape. However, this level of drama may feel like too much if you prefer a more natural look.

Key Tradeoffs to Consider

The main tradeoff between The Bestie and a dramatic style like The Flirt is subtlety versus impact. The Bestie offers a wispy, natural finish that blends seamlessly with your lashes, but it may not provide enough volume for those who want a full glam look. On the other hand, a dramatic style delivers bold lift and curl but can look overwhelming on smaller or rounder eyes.

Another factor is application ease. The Bestie features PrepTECHTM patent-pending technology with pre-placed micro adhesive dots and an ultra-thin barrier, making placement easier and improving hold. This is a clear advantage for DIY beginners or anyone who wants a quicker routine. A dramatic style like The Flirt also includes this technology, so you don't have to sacrifice ease for impact.

How to Choose Based on Your Eye Shape

Eye shape plays a big role in how lash styles look on you. Almond eyes are versatile and can pull off most styles, but The Bestie's wispy texture enhances their natural symmetry. Round eyes benefit from the elongated effect of a tapered inner corner, which The Bestie provides.

For hooded or monolid eyes, a dramatic curl and volume help create the appearance of a lifted lid. If that's your goal, consider a style like The Flirt instead of The Bestie, which may not offer enough lift. If you're unsure, start with The Bestie for a natural everyday look and experiment with a dramatic style for special occasions.

The Tradeoff: Natural vs. Dramatic

  • The Bestie: Natural Wispy Finish: Offers gentle spikes and a tapered inner corner for a soft, textured look that blends with your natural lashes. Ideal for everyday wear and almond or round eyes. Choose The Bestie if you want a subtle, versatile lash that enhances without overpowering.
  • The Flirt: Bold Lift and Curl: Provides dramatic volume and eye-opening curl, designed to replace a full set of extensions. Best for hooded or monolid eyes that need extra lift. Choose The Flirt if you crave drama and want to make a statement.
  • Application Ease: Both The Bestie and The Flirt feature PrepTECHTM technology with pre-placed micro adhesive dots and an ultra-thin barrier for easier placement and improved hold. Either style is beginner-friendly, so focus on the look you want rather than worrying about difficulty.

Product Facts at a Glance

  • The Bestie: Featuring gentle spikes, subtle length variation throughout, and a softly tapered inner corner, The Bestie is an elevated, wispy lash that adds texture without overpowering your look. It’s the perfect next step for lovers of The Sweetheart® or Shorties®. Now featuring PrepTECHTM patent-pending technology, each segment includes pre-placed micro adhesive dots and an ultra-thin barrier for easier placement and improved hold. The wispy texture and tapered inner corner make The Bestie ideal for almond and round eyes, adding soft definition without overwhelming your natural features. The PrepTECHTM technology simplifies DIY application, saving you time and reducing the risk of placement errors.
  • The Flirt: More volume, more curl, more drama. If you’re looking for a flirty style that brings the drama, The Flirt is the one for you. Designed to replace a full set of extensions, this style delivers bold lift, eye-opening curl, and unapologetic glam in every segment. Now featuring PrepTECHTM patent-pending technology, each segment includes pre-placed micro adhesive dots and an ultra-thin barrier for easier placement and improved hold. If you have hooded or monolid eyes and want a dramatic, lifted look, The Flirt offers the bold curl and volume that The Bestie lacks. Its PrepTECHTM technology ensures easy application even with a more dramatic style.

Which Style Fits You Best?

Best For

  • Almond or round eyes that want a natural, wispy everyday lash
  • Anyone who prefers a subtle, textured look over full glam

Not For

  • Hooded or monolid eyes that need a dramatic lift and curl—consider The Flirt instead
  • Those who want maximum volume and a bold cat-eye effect

When choosing between The Bestie and a dramatic style like The Flirt, let your eye shape and desired impact guide you. The Bestie offers a natural, wispy finish that flatters almond and round eyes, while The Flirt delivers the bold lift that hooded or monolid eyes may need. Consider your daily routine and comfort level, and you'll find the perfect match for your DIY lash look.