Two Nursing-Friendly Shirts, Two Different Silhouettes
If you're shopping for a nursing-friendly top that works during pregnancy and postpartum, The Classic Buttondown and The Aubrey Shirt from HATCH Collection both offer easy button-front access. But they serve different wardrobes. The Classic Buttondown is an intentionally oversized cotton shirting piece with structure and stretch. The Aubrey Shirt is a lightweight gauzy top, part of a matching set. Your choice depends on whether you want a polished, structured layer or an airy, relaxed piece.
Quick Look at the Evidence
-
The Classic Buttondown: Intentionally oversized silhouette designed to accommodate a changing body; lightweight cotton shirting with subtle stretch for comfort and structure. This top is meant to fit loosely from the start, giving you room to grow without changing sizes. The stretch in the cotton shirting adds comfort and helps the shirt keep its shape.
The Classic Buttondown
-
The Aubrey Shirt: Lightweight gauzy fabric; nursing-friendly button front; part of a matching set. The gauzy fabric is airy and less structured, ideal for warm weather or casual wear. Being part of a matching set means you can pair it with coordinating bottoms for a put-together look with minimal effort.
The Aubrey Shirt
Silhouette and Structure: Oversized vs. Gauzy
The Classic Buttondown is built with an intentionally oversized silhouette. That means it's designed to be roomy even before pregnancy, so it can accommodate your changing body without needing a size change. The cotton shirting has subtle stretch, which gives it structure and helps it hold its shape throughout the day.
The Aubrey Shirt is made from lightweight gauzy fabric. Gauze is typically softer and more drapey, with less structure. It will skim your body rather than hold a crisp shape. If you prefer a top that feels barely there and flows with movement, the Aubrey Shirt is the lighter option.
- Classic Buttondown: Oversized fit, cotton shirting with stretch, structured shape.
- Aubrey Shirt: Lightweight gauzy fabric, relaxed drape, less structure.
Nursing Access: Both Button Front, Different Feel
Both tops feature a front button closure designed for nursing-friendly access. But the experience will differ because of the fabric. The Classic Buttondown's stiffer cotton shirting means the buttons stay in place and the placket opens cleanly. The Aubrey Shirt's gauzy fabric is softer, so the placket may not hold its shape as firmly, but it still provides easy access.
Neither product record specifies nursing clip details or one-handed opening, so for both tops, you'll need to unbutton with two hands. The key difference is the tactile feel: structured vs. soft.
- Classic Buttondown: Structured placket stays open; buttons are easy to manage.
- Aubrey Shirt: Soft gauze placket; still functional but less crisp.
Styling and Versatility: Work vs. Weekend
The Classic Buttondown's tailored details—crisp collar, inverted back pleat, and tailored cuffs—make it suitable for work settings or occasions where you want a more polished look. It can be tucked into trousers or left untucked over leggings.
The Aubrey Shirt is part of a matching set, which suggests it's designed for coordinated, effortless outfits. The gauzy fabric and stripe colorways (Ivory Black Stripe and Pink Green Stripe) give it a more casual, weekend-friendly vibe. It's a good choice for brunch, errands, or lounging.
- Classic Buttondown: Work-appropriate, can be dressed up or down, versatile across seasons.
- Aubrey Shirt: Casual, matching set option, best for warm weather or relaxed days.
Sizing and Availability
The Classic Buttondown is available in sizes XS through XL in three colorways: Camel Plaid, Pink Raspberry Stripe, and Purple Pink Stripe. The Aubrey Shirt also runs XS through XL, in two colorways: Ivory Black Stripe and Pink Green Stripe.
Both tops offer a range of sizes, but the Classic Buttondown has more color options. If you're between sizes, the Classic Buttondown's intentional oversize gives you more leeway; the Aubrey Shirt's relaxed fit also forgives size fluctuations, but the gauze fabric may cling more if you choose a size that's too snug.
- Classic Buttondown: XS–XL, 3 colorways, oversized fit accommodates size changes.
- Aubrey Shirt: XS–XL, 2 colorways, relaxed fit but less forgiving fabric if too tight.
What the Records Don't Tell You
Neither product record includes care instructions, so we can't confirm whether either top requires special washing (e.g., cold water, hang dry). The Classic Buttondown's cotton shirting with stretch is likely machine-washable, but treat this as unconfirmed. The Aubrey Shirt's gauzy fabric may be more delicate. Also absent is any information about shrinkage, so if that's a concern, consider sizing up. Finally, there's no evidence on thermal performance or sun protection—these are not performance garments.
Which Top Should You Choose?
Choose The Classic Buttondown if you want a structured, work-ready top that will last through pregnancy and beyond, with an oversized fit that doesn't require constant size changes. Its tailored details and stretch cotton make it a wardrobe anchor.
Choose The Aubrey Shirt if you prefer an airy, lightweight top for casual days, especially if you like the idea of a matching set. It's a low-effort, comfortable option for warm weather or relaxed settings.




