Two Materials, One Goal: Gradual Anal Training
Both the Toosh Metal and Toosh Silicone Butt Plug Sets solve the same problem: they give you three graduated sizes in one box so you can progress from Small to Medium to Large at your own pace, without buying separate toys. The real choice comes down to material feel, weight, and lubricant compatibility.
The metal sets (available in Gold or Silver) are solid aluminium alloy with a seamless, non-porous surface. The silicone sets (available in Black or Purple) use body-safe silicone with an ABS jewelled base. Each has distinct handling and care requirements that affect daily use.
Metal vs Silicone at a Glance
The table below highlights the key differences that matter most when choosing between the two materials.
- Feel and weight: Metal plugs are rigid, cool to the touch, and noticeably heavier — the Large metal plug weighs 148g. Silicone plugs are lighter (the Large silicone plug is about 80g), flexible, and warm up to body temperature quickly.
- Lubricant compatibility: The metal sets work with water-based, silicone-based, or oil-based lubricant. The silicone sets require water-based lubricant only — silicone-based formulas will break down the material over repeated use.
- Surface and cleaning: Both materials are seamless and easy to clean. The non-porous metal surface has no mould lines to trap residue. The silicone surface is smooth but more porous; both wipe clean between sessions.
- Temperature play: Metal holds temperature well — you can warm or cool the plug before use. Silicone stays at room temperature and warms to body heat but doesn't retain external temperature changes.
Size Progression Across Both Sets
-
Toosh Metal Butt Plug Gold Set of 3 Clear Stone: The Toosh Metal Butt Plug Gold Set includes Small (2.45" insertable, 1.1" width), Medium (2.75" insertable, 1.3" width), and Large (3.2" insertable, 1.57" width). The metal set's sizes are nearly identical to the silicone set, so your choice depends on material preference rather than size availability. The slight differences in insertable length and width are negligible for most users.
Toosh Metal Butt Plug Gold Set of 3 Clear Stone
-
Toosh Silicone Butt Plug Black Set of 3 Clear Stone: The Toosh Silicone Butt Plug Black Set includes Small (2.5" insertable, 1.1" width), Medium (2.75" insertable, 1.35" width), and Large (3.3" insertable, 1.7" width). The silicone set offers a slightly wider Large plug (1.7" vs 1.57"), which may suit users who want a more gradual final step. The insertable lengths are very close to the metal set.
Toosh Silicone Butt Plug Black Set of 3 Clear Stone
When to Choose the Metal Set
Choose the Toosh Metal Butt Plug Set if you prefer a firm, unyielding sensation with noticeable weight. The rigid aluminium alloy delivers a solid presence that doesn't compress, and the cool-to-touch surface adds a distinct sensory element. The non-porous metal also gives you more lubricant options — you can use silicone-based formulas without worrying about surface degradation.
The metal set is also a good pick if you want to experiment with temperature play. Because the plugs are solid metal, you can warm them under warm water or cool them briefly before use. The weight of the Large plug (148g) provides a fuller feeling compared to the lighter silicone equivalent.
When to Choose the Silicone Set
Choose the Toosh Silicone Butt Plug Set if you want a softer, more forgiving feel that warms to body temperature quickly. Silicone has a slight give, which can feel more comfortable for beginners or for longer wear sessions. The lighter weight (the Large silicone plug is about 80g) means less drag on the pelvic floor muscles during extended use.
The silicone set is also the more affordable option — the Black set is priced at USD 19.79, while the metal sets start at USD 18.89 for Silver and USD 22.04 for Gold. If budget is a factor, the silicone set delivers the same graduated training format at a lower price point.
Keep in mind that silicone plugs require water-based lubricant only. Silicone-based lubricants will interact with the plug's surface and wear it down over repeated use.
Both Sets Share the Same Safety Design
Regardless of material, every Toosh plug follows the same safety-first shape: a tapered tip for easy insertion, a slim neck that holds the plug in position, and a flared base that stays outside the body to prevent over-insertion. Both sets include a clear stone accent on the base for visual polish.
Neither set requires batteries or charging — they are manual toys that rely on size, shape, and lubricant. Both ship in discreet packaging with no markings indicating the contents or sender.

