Quick Answer
Choose the Montecristo Short if you want the lower upfront price and a classic Montecristo profile in a compact format. Choose the Trinidad Short if you prefer the Trinidad brand’s legacy and don’t mind paying more for a Cuban cigarillo in plain packaging.
Price and packaging: what the numbers tell you
The Montecristo Short lists at $29.76 for a single pack, compared with $36.92 for the Trinidad Short — about a $7 difference. Both are available in 1-pack or 5-pack options, so you can scale up without committing to a full box. The Trinidad Short comes in plain packaging, which keeps the focus on the cigar itself rather than presentation. If you often buy several packs at once, that price gap adds up quickly and may push you toward the Montecristo for everyday smoking.
Brand character and Cuban origin
Both cigarillos are Cuban, so you’re getting the same country of origin. The real difference is the brand’s house style. Montecristo is widely known for a balanced, medium-bodied character, while Trinidad carries a reputation for a slightly more refined, complex profile. Since both are short formats, the experience is condensed — you’ll get a quick impression of each brand rather than a full-length journey. Neither product listing provides specific wrapper, binder, or filler details, so if you rely on those specifications, treat this as a limitation and choose based on brand familiarity instead.
When the cheaper option isn’t the better one
If you smoke cigarillos only occasionally, the Montecristo Short’s lower price makes it an easy entry point. But if you already enjoy Trinidad’s larger cigars and want a short smoke that echoes that experience, the Trinidad Short is worth the extra cost. The plain packaging also makes it a practical choice when you don’t need a fancy presentation. Just keep in mind that neither cigarillo is designed for long sessions — both are short-format smokes best enjoyed within a short break.
Key Trade-Offs to Weigh
- Price vs. brand prestige: The Montecristo Short costs less per pack, while the Trinidad Short carries a higher price tag tied to its brand legacy. If you smoke daily, the savings from Montecristo add up; if you want a special short smoke, Trinidad justifies the cost.
- Packaging simplicity vs. presentation: Trinidad Short comes in plain packaging, which some smokers prefer for its no-frills approach. Montecristo Short uses standard packaging. Neither is inherently better — decide whether you care about presentation or just the cigar. If you often gift cigarillos, plain packaging may feel less formal.
- Flavor profile guesswork: Since neither listing details the blend, you can’t compare wrapper or filler. Use brand reputation as your guide: Montecristo for a classic, approachable profile; Trinidad for a potentially more complex experience. Buy a single pack first to test before committing to a 5-pack.
Product Facts
-
Trinidad Short: Cuban cigarillo from Trinidad, offered in plain packaging and available in 1-pack or 5-pack options. Plain packaging keeps the focus on the cigar, and the multi-pack option lets you stock up without buying a full box.
Trinidad Short
-
Montecristo Short: Cuban cigarillo from Montecristo, available in 1 Pack or 5 Packs. The lower price per pack makes it a budget-friendly way to enjoy a quick, satisfying smoke.
Montecristo Short
Which Should You Choose?
Best for
- Smokers who want a lower-cost Cuban cigarillo for everyday quick breaks
- Fans of Montecristo’s classic brand character in a compact size
- Buyers who prefer standard packaging over plain wraps
Not for
- Smokers who specifically want the Trinidad brand experience
- Those who prefer plain, no-frills packaging
- Buyers looking for a longer smoking session — both are short formats
