Quick answer
Choose Trojan Magnum XL if you need extra room and prefer a lubricated fit; choose Trojan BareSkin EveryTHIN if you want ultra-thin sensation and a variety of textures. Neither is universally better—fit and feel priorities decide.
Fit and sensation trade-offs
Magnum XL is designed for a larger fit with added lubrication, reducing tightness and friction for those who find standard condoms constricting. BareSkin EveryTHIN focuses on thinness—Trojan's thinnest options—and includes textured and raw versions for varied sensation. The trade-off: extra room may reduce the snug, thin feel some prefer, while ultra-thin condoms may feel tighter and offer less lubrication unless added.
When size uncertainty matters
If you're unsure of your size, Magnum XL's larger fit can be more forgiving, but it may be too loose for average girth. BareSkin EveryTHIN, while thin, still follows standard sizing; if standard condoms feel tight, it won't solve that. Neither product lists exact dimensions, so base your choice on past experience with standard vs. large condoms.
Key trade-offs
- Fit vs. thinness: Magnum XL prioritizes room; BareSkin EveryTHIN prioritizes thin sensation. If standard condoms feel tight, Magnum XL may be more comfortable; if you want maximum sensitivity, BareSkin EveryTHIN is the pick.
- Lubrication: Magnum XL comes lubricated for smooth glide; BareSkin EveryTHIN's lubrication level isn't specified, so you may need extra lube, especially with the Raw version. Keep water-based lube handy if you choose BareSkin.
- Variety vs. consistency: BareSkin EveryTHIN offers three thin styles to explore; Magnum XL provides a consistent large fit. Choose based on whether you value experimentation or a reliable go-to.
Product facts
-
Trojan BareSkin EveryTHIN Condom - Variety Pack of 10: Variety pack includes Trojan BareSkin Raw, original BareSkin, and Studded BareSkin—all ultra-thin. Lets you test different textures and thinness levels without committing to a full box of one style.
Trojan BareSkin EveryTHIN Condom - Variety Pack of 10
-
Trojan Magnum XL Lubricated Condom - Box of 12: Large Magnum size with lubrication in a 12-count box. Provides extra room and glide for those who need a larger fit, reducing the chance of tightness or breakage.
Trojan Magnum XL Lubricated Condom - Box of 12
Which should you choose?
Best for
- Those who need a larger fit and prefer lubricated condoms
- Users who find standard condoms too tight
Not for
- Those who prefer ultra-thin sensation over extra room
- Anyone who needs a snug, standard fit