Same price, same count, one real difference

Two Dozen Gourmets and Two Dozen Peanut Butter Gourmets sit side by side in the catalog at USD 25.00 each, down from a comparison price of USD 49.99. Both arrive as two dozen gourmet cookies in a gift box. The decision comes down to whether the child you're buying for wants a sure thing or a surprise.

The peanut butter version is built around one flavor. The standard Two Dozen Gourmets is described as a cookie gift box filled with two dozen gourmet cookies, without naming specific flavors in the supplied catalog text. That makes the peanut butter box the safer pick for a child who already loves peanut butter, and the mixed box the better fit for a child who likes variety or a household where several kids will share.

What the catalog confirms about each box

  • Two Dozen Peanut Butter Gourmets: Two Dozen Peanut Butter Gourmets: peanut butter gourmet cookies, sold by the dozen, with the catalog suggesting milk on hand by the gallon. The single-flavor focus is the main reason to choose this box for a peanut butter fan.

    Two Dozen Peanut Butter Gourmets

    Two Dozen Peanut Butter Gourmets

  • Two Dozen Gourmets: Two Dozen Gourmets: a cookie gift box filled with two dozen gourmet cookies, described as freshly baked treats that go fast. This is the assortment option when you want variety rather than one flavor.

    Two Dozen Gourmets

    Two Dozen Gourmets

Which box fits which child

  • Choose Two Dozen Peanut Butter Gourmets if...: The child already asks for peanut butter cookies, or you want a gift where every cookie is a known favorite. The catalog's own note about having milk ready suggests it's a rich, familiar treat.
  • Choose Two Dozen Gourmets if...: You're buying for siblings, a classroom, or a child who likes trying different cookies. The assortment format gives more than one flavor experience, though the supplied catalog text doesn't list which flavors are included.

What the catalog does not tell you

Neither product record lists ingredients, allergens, storage instructions, or a shelf life. If a peanut allergy or other dietary restriction is a factor, treat the peanut butter box as off the table until you confirm ingredients with the store, and ask about the assortment's contents before relying on it for a child with specific preferences.

The records also don't confirm whether either box includes a tin or basket. The product names and descriptions refer to a gift box, so plan your presentation around that rather than expecting a keepsake container.

A quick way to settle it

  • Ask one question: Does the child have a favorite cookie flavor? If the answer is peanut butter, the Peanut Butter Gourmets is the direct match. If the answer is 'all of them,' the Two Dozen Gourmets assortment is the better bet.
  • Check the price the same day: Both boxes are listed at USD 25.00 against a USD 49.99 comparison price. Confirm the current price and any delivery timing before you order, since those details can change.