Two Grain-Free Canned Foods, Different Protein Bases
When choosing a canned dog food, the protein source often drives the decision. Wellness Chicken Stew features real chicken as the first ingredient, while Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Lamb Dinner starts with real lamb. Both are grain-free, contain vegetables, and are formulated for adult dogs. This comparison breaks down their ingredient differences, texture, and how to use each one.
Key Product Facts at a Glance
-
Wellness Chicken Stew Peas Carrots 12.5 oz Can: Wellness Chicken Stew is a chunky, slow-cooked homestyle stew with tender cuts of chicken, peas, and carrots in a savory gravy. It contains no corn, wheat, or soy and is made without poultry by-products. The stew texture and visible vegetables appeal to dogs who enjoy variety, and the absence of common fillers supports sensitive digestion.
Wellness Chicken Stew Peas Carrots 12.5 oz Can
-
Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Adult Wet Dog Food, Made with Natural Ingredients, Lamb Dinner With Garden Vegetables, 12.5-oz. Can: Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Lamb Dinner is made with real lamb as the first ingredient, with garden vegetables like carrots, peas, and sweet potatoes. It is grain-free and contains no chicken or poultry by-product meals. Lamb is a novel protein for some dogs, and the inclusion of sweet potatoes provides a different carbohydrate source compared to the peas and potatoes in the Wellness stew.
Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Adult Wet Dog Food, Made with Natural Ingredients, Lamb Dinner With Garden Vegetables, 12.5-oz. Can
Ingredient and Texture Differences
Wellness Chicken Stew uses chicken, chicken broth, and chicken liver as primary protein sources, with peas, carrots, and potatoes. It is a chunky stew with a thick gravy. Blue Buffalo Lamb Dinner lists lamb, beef broth, and liver first, with carrots, peas, brown rice, sweet potatoes, barley, and oatmeal. Note that Blue Buffalo contains grains (brown rice, barley, oatmeal) despite being labeled grain-free? The supplied facts confirm it is grain-free, so those grains are not present. The ingredient list includes brown rice and barley, which are grains. This is a discrepancy. The supplied facts state it is grain-free, but the ingredient list includes grains. For accuracy, rely on the supplied facts: Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe is described as grain-free. However, the ingredient list shows brown rice, barley, and oatmeal. This may be an error in the source data. For this comparison, we note that Blue Buffalo's ingredient list includes grains, while Wellness Chicken Stew is explicitly grain-free with no grains listed. The texture of Wellness is a chunky stew; Blue Buffalo is a pâté-style dinner. Dogs may prefer one texture over the other.
- Wellness Chicken Stew: Chunky stew with chicken, peas, carrots, and potatoes in gravy. Grain-free. No corn, wheat, soy, or poultry by-products. Feeding: ¾ can per 8 lbs body weight per day for adults.
- Blue Buffalo Lamb Dinner: Pâté-style texture with lamb, garden vegetables (carrots, peas, sweet potatoes), and grains (brown rice, barley, oatmeal) per ingredient list. Grain-free per supplied facts. No chicken by-product meals. No specific feeding amounts supplied.
Feeding as a Complete Meal or Topper
Both foods can be served as a complete and balanced meal. Wellness Chicken Stew is explicitly labeled as complete and balanced for adult dogs, and can also be used as a meal mixer or topper. Blue Buffalo Lamb Dinner is also a complete meal, though the supplied facts do not specify topper use. If your dog is a picky eater, the chunky texture of Wellness or the pâté smoothness of Blue Buffalo may influence acceptance. Always feed at room temperature and refrigerate unused portions.
Honest Trade-Offs to Consider
Wellness Chicken Stew provides a clear grain-free formula with a single protein source (chicken) and visible vegetables. It is slightly cheaper at $2.59 per 12.5 oz can compared to Blue Buffalo's $2.62. Blue Buffalo offers lamb as a first ingredient, which can be beneficial for dogs with chicken sensitivities, but its ingredient list includes grains (brown rice, barley, oatmeal) despite being marketed as grain-free in the supplied facts. This inconsistency may matter to owners who strictly avoid grains. Neither food contains artificial colors or preservatives. Both are made in the USA with globally sourced ingredients. Your choice depends on your dog's protein preference, texture preference, and whether you want a strictly grain-free formula (Wellness) or a lamb-based option (Blue Buffalo).




