Two winter teas, two different moods
When the weather turns cold, a warm cup of tea feels like the right response. Harney & Sons offers two seasonal options that look similar in the tin but deliver completely different experiences: White Christmas Tea and Peppermint Herbal. The real question is not which is better, but which fits the moment you are in.
White Christmas Tea is a black tea blend with a warm, nutty character, designed to evoke a cozy winter evening by the fire. Peppermint Herbal is a caffeine-free tisane made from Washington State peppermint leaves, known for its crisp, aromatic punch and a reputation for settling the stomach. One is about comfort and indulgence; the other is about clarity and refreshment.
White Christmas Tea vs. Peppermint Herbal at a glance
The table below captures the key differences between these two teas based on the supplied catalog information.
- Flavor profile: White Christmas Tea is described as a warm and nutty blend, evoking a winter wonderland. Peppermint Herbal is a wonderfully aromatic and crisp-tasting tisane.
- Caffeine: White Christmas Tea is a black tea blend and contains caffeine. Peppermint Herbal is a tisane (herbal infusion) and is naturally caffeine-free.
- Serving size: White Christmas Tea comes in a tin of 20 sachets. Peppermint Herbal comes in an HRP tin of 30 sachets. Each sachet brews one 12 oz. cup.
- Best use case: White Christmas Tea suits a cozy, indulgent moment—think fireside sipping or a holiday dessert pairing. Peppermint Herbal works as a palate cleanser, an after-dinner digestive, or a refreshing caffeine-free option any time.
- Tin reuse: Both tins are recyclable. The Peppermint Herbal tin can be refilled with a Bag of 50 sachets. White Christmas Tea tin reuse is encouraged but specific refill options are not detailed in the supplied information.
When to reach for White Christmas Tea
White Christmas Tea is built for the feeling of a perfect winter night. The catalog describes it as a sip that completes a winter wonderland, with a warm and nutty flavor that pairs naturally with sweet baked goods or a quiet evening. If you are looking for a tea that feels like a seasonal treat and you do not mind the caffeine, this is the one to grab.
It contains 20 sachets per tin, each brewing a standard 12 oz. cup. The tin itself is designed to be reusable or recyclable, though the catalog does not specify a direct refill option for this blend.
White Christmas Tea facts
-
White Christmas Tea, Tin of 20 Sachets: A sip from this warm and nutty blend completes the perfect winter wonderland. Confirms the flavor profile is sweet, cozy, and indulgent—ideal for holiday relaxation.
White Christmas Tea, Tin of 20 Sachets
-
White Christmas Tea, Tin of 20 Sachets: Each tin contains 20 tea sachets. Each sachet brews one 12 oz. cup of tea. Helps you plan how many servings you get and confirms the standard cup size.
When to reach for Peppermint Herbal
Peppermint Herbal is the choice when you want something brisk and caffeine-free. The peppermint leaves come from Washington State and produce a crisp, aromatic cup. The catalog also notes that a cup of Peppermint can help settle a pesky stomach, making it a practical choice after a heavy meal or when you need a gentle digestive aid.
With 30 sachets per tin, it offers more servings than the White Christmas Tea tin. The HRP tin can be refilled with a Bag of 50 sachets, which is a useful detail if you plan to keep it stocked through the winter.
Peppermint Herbal facts
-
Peppermint Herbal, HRP Tin of 30 Sachets: Our marvelously brisk Peppermint comes from Washington State, and the leaves produce a wonderfully aromatic and crisp-tasting tisane. Confirms the origin and flavor profile—bright, clean, and refreshing.
Peppermint Herbal, HRP Tin of 30 Sachets
-
Peppermint Herbal, HRP Tin of 30 Sachets: We find a cup of Peppermint can also get a pesky stomach under control in no time. Highlights a practical digestive benefit that sets it apart from the White Christmas blend.
-
Peppermint Herbal, HRP Tin of 30 Sachets: Each HRP tin contains 30 tea sachets. Each sachet brews one 12 oz. cup of tea. More sachets per tin than White Christmas, and the tin can be refilled with a Bag of 50.
How to choose between the two
Think about the occasion and your caffeine preference. If you are winding down in the evening and want a caffeine-free option that also aids digestion, Peppermint Herbal is the straightforward pick. If you are looking for a festive, comforting cup that pairs with a sweet treat or a cozy blanket, White Christmas Tea delivers that mood.
Both teas come in attractive tins that can be reused or recycled, but only the Peppermint Herbal tin has a confirmed refill option (Bag of 50) from the supplied information. For a one-time seasonal treat, White Christmas Tea is a lovely choice. For a longer-term staple, Peppermint Herbal offers more servings and refillability.
Limits to know before you buy
The catalog does not specify the exact ingredients or allergen information for either tea. If you have dietary restrictions or allergies, you will need to check the packaging or contact Harney & Sons directly. Similarly, no steeping times or water temperatures are provided, so you will need to rely on general black tea or herbal tea guidelines.
The White Christmas Tea is a seasonal blend, so it may not be available year-round. Peppermint Herbal is a standard offering and likely more consistently in stock.




