Quick answer
Choose the Annabelle costume for a recognizable, size-specific doll look, or the Billy Chapman costume for a complete one-size-fits-most Santa disguise with an axe prop.
What you get in the box
The Billy Chapman costume includes a jacket, pants, belt, hat, beard, gloves, and an axe — everything you need to become the killer Santa. The Annabelle costume comes with a dress, wig, and a cardboard "Miss Me?" card, so you supply the shoes and any makeup.
Sizing and fit differences
Billy Chapman is one size fits most, which simplifies ordering but may not fit everyone perfectly. Annabelle is available in Small, Medium, Large, and Extra Large, giving you more control over the fit.
Screen accuracy and license
Both are officially licensed replicas based on screen-used costumes. The Billy Chapman set mirrors the Santa suit from Silent Night, Deadly Night, while the Annabelle dress is an enlarged replica of the actual doll's dress from The Conjuring.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Completeness: Billy Chapman includes a full outfit plus axe; Annabelle requires you to source shoes and makeup.
- Sizing control: Annabelle offers four sizes; Billy Chapman is one size fits most.
- Recognition factor: Annabelle is widely known from The Conjuring films; Billy Chapman is a cult classic from Silent Night, Deadly Night. Choose based on which horror franchise your group will recognize.
Product facts
-
Silent Night Deadly Night - Billy Chapman Costume with Axe: Items included: jacket, pants, belt, hat, beard, gloves, and axe. One size fits most. You get a complete outfit with a prop weapon in one purchase, but you cannot choose a specific size.
Silent Night Deadly Night - Billy Chapman Costume with Axe
-
The Conjuring - Annabelle Costume: Items included: dress, wig and cardboard 'Miss Me?' card. Available in Small, Medium, Large and Extra Large. You can pick your size for a better fit, but you will need to add shoes and possibly makeup to complete the look.
The Conjuring - Annabelle Costume
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Annabelle: horror fans who want a size-specific, instantly recognizable doll costume from a blockbuster franchise
- Billy Chapman: collectors and fans of 80s slasher films who want a complete, prop-included Santa outfit
Not for
- Annabelle: if you want a complete outfit with no extra shopping
- Billy Chapman: if you need a precise fit or are outside average adult sizing
