Quick Answer

The best board game accessories are those that solve a real problem at your table: improving component readability, speeding up setup, or adding replay value. For most players, acrylic tokens and deluxe editions offer the biggest practical upgrade. Focus on accessories that match how often you play and what annoys you most during a game.

Game nights are about the people and the fun, but the right accessories can turn a good game into a great one. Whether it's clearer tokens, smoother setup, or extra content, small additions can make a big difference. This guide breaks down the types of accessories that truly matter and how to choose them.

We'll look at real products from Roxley Games and give you concrete rules for deciding what's worth your money. You'll learn what to look for in component upgrades, how to judge expansion content, and when to skip a 'deluxe' version.

Why Component Quality Changes How You Play

Good components don't just look nice; they improve readability and feel. If you've ever squinted at a board to tell two tokens apart, you know the frustration. Upgrading to acrylic tokens or better player pieces can reduce mistakes and keep everyone focused on strategy.

For example, in a game like Santorini, where placement and visibility are key, clear tokens matter. In Brass: Birmingham, the Iron Clays included in the Deluxe Edition are not just pretty—they're easier to handle and count than paper money. That might sound minor, but it speeds up transactions and reduces errors.

Consider how often you play a game. If a title hits the table weekly, a component upgrade is worth it. If it's a once-a-year play, you might be fine with the base components.

  • Look for accessories that improve readability or speed up setup.
  • Think about the tactile feel—do the components feel good to handle?
  • Check if the accessory is compatible with your edition.

Acrylic Tokens: A Clear Upgrade

Acrylic tokens are a popular upgrade because they're durable, colorful, and often easier to distinguish than cardboard or wood. For games with lots of tokens or those that require frequent picking up and placing, acrylic can be a game-changer.

Roxley offers acrylic tokens for Santorini, such as the Pantheon Acrylic Tokens Bundle. These are designed to replace standard tokens, providing a premium feel and better visibility. However, they come at a higher price, so weigh the cost against how much you play.

If you're a collector or play often, the investment makes sense. If you're on a budget, consider whether the base components are truly problematic.

  • Acrylic tokens are best for games with high token turnover.
  • They are more durable than cardboard but can be slippery—test them on your table.
  • Check if the bundle includes all token types you need.

Expansions and Add-Ons: More Content, More Fun

Expansions add new mechanics, scenarios, or components that can breathe new life into a game you love. But not all expansions are equal. Some add meaningful depth; others just complicate things.

For example, Santorini: Riddle of the Sphinx is an expansion that adds new god powers and a new board, increasing variety. Similarly, Radlands Hazmats is an add-on that introduces new cards for the Radlands game, offering more strategic options.

When considering an expansion, ask: Does it fix a flaw in the base game, or does it just add more? Does it increase setup time significantly? Is it compatible with the edition you own? Expansions that integrate seamlessly and offer real choices are usually worth it.

  • Read reviews to see if the expansion is well-received.
  • Check compatibility with your specific edition.
  • Consider if the expansion increases replay value or just adds complexity.

Deluxe Editions: When to Splurge

Deluxe editions bundle upgraded components, expansions, and stretch goals into one package. They can be a great value if you want everything, but they can also be overkill if you only play casually.

The Brass: Birmingham Deluxe Edition includes Iron Clays and all Kickstarter stretch goals, offering a premium experience. Similarly, Radlands Complete might bundle the base game with expansions and upgrades. These are excellent for enthusiasts who want the definitive version.

However, if you already own the base game, buying a deluxe edition might mean duplicating components. In that case, buying individual accessories or expansions might be more cost-effective.

  • Deluxe editions are best for new players or collectors.
  • Check what's included vs. what you already have.
  • Compare the price of the deluxe to buying components separately.

Decision Rules for Buying Accessories

  • Rule 1: Frequency over novelty: Only buy accessories for games you play at least once a month. If a game sits on the shelf, the upgrade won't be used. Upgrade your most-played games first.
  • Rule 2: Compatibility check: Verify that the accessory or expansion matches your edition. Deluxe editions may not work with older versions. Always read the product details for edition compatibility.
  • Rule 3: Budget for the whole picture: Set a budget for upgrades per game. If a deluxe edition costs more than the base game plus individual upgrades, consider buying separately. Compare total costs before committing.

Product Facts

  • Santorini Pantheon Acrylic Tokens Bundle - case of 24: Catalog price USD 93.60 (compare at USD 187.20). No other catalog facts supplied. This bundle is aimed at retailers or groups who need multiple sets. For individual players, a single set might be more appropriate, but the bulk price could be economical if you're outfitting a game library.
  • Brass: Birmingham: Deluxe Edition, containing the Iron Clays, and all Kickstarter stretch goals. Features dynamic board setup, core rules true to the original, new canal/rail scoring, and three new industry types. The Iron Clays are a tactile upgrade over paper money, and the stretch goals add content that would otherwise be separate purchases. The dynamic setup increases replayability, making this deluxe edition a strong choice for fans.
  • Radlands Hazmats: Catalog price USD 15.00 (compare at USD 30.00). No other catalog facts supplied. This add-on provides new cards for Radlands, expanding strategic options. At a lower price point, it's an accessible way to refresh a game you already enjoy.

Which Accessory Fits You?

Best for

  • Enthusiasts who play a few games regularly and want to enhance the tactile experience.
  • Collectors who appreciate deluxe components and complete editions.

Not for

  • Casual players who rarely get the same game to the table.
  • Budget-conscious buyers who are satisfied with base components.

The right accessory can make your favorite games feel new again, but it's important to choose based on your play habits and needs. Prioritize upgrades for games you love and play often, check compatibility, and compare costs. With these rules, you'll make smart choices that enhance your game nights for years to come.