Quick answer

Choose Boy Butter Original Formula if you want a thick, buttery cream that never dries out or gets tacky and still rinses away like a water-soluble product. Choose the water-based H2O formula if you want a crystal-clear, glass-like glide that mimics natural moisture and pairs easily with toys. Both are water-soluble at cleanup, so the real decision comes down to texture, endurance, and how you play.

The core difference: creamy oil-based endurance vs clear water-based glide

Boy Butter Original Formula is an oil-based lubricant that has been made water-soluble, so it delivers the rich, buttery endurance of an oil while rinsing away with water. It lays down a thick, friction-free barrier that never dries out, gets tacky, or kills the vibe, which is why it is engineered for marathon sessions.

The water-based H2O formula takes the opposite approach. It is ultra-concentrated and powered by Invisagel technology to mimic natural moisture with a smooth, glass-like glide. It stays 100% water-soluble, so it cleans up easily and is a natural fit when you want a clear, lightweight feel rather than a cream.

How to choose based on your session and cleanup

If your priority is a cushiony layer that stays put through long sessions, the Original Formula's coconut oil and shea butter blend gives you that creamy, whipped texture. If your priority is a clean, barely-there feel that mimics your own moisture, the H2O formula's clear gel is the better match.

Both formulas share one practical advantage: they are water-soluble, so you are not trading easy cleanup for endurance. That means the decision is mostly about whether you want the richness of a cream or the transparency of a water-based gel.

Size and value at a glance

The Original Formula comes in a 6 oz tube and a 25 oz squeeze bottle, so you can test the texture before committing to the larger size. The water-based H2O formula comes in an 8 oz squeeze bottle, which sits between the two Original sizes and suits regular water-based users who want a mid-size supply.

Trade-offs to weigh before you buy

  • Texture: Original Formula is a thick, whipped cream; the H2O formula is a clear, lightweight gel. Pick cream for cushion, gel for a barely-there feel.
  • Endurance: Original Formula is built to never dry out or get tacky during long sessions; the H2O formula mimics natural moisture and may need reapplication sooner depending on your body. Long sessions favor Original; shorter or toy-focused sessions favor H2O.
  • Cleanup: Both are water-soluble, so neither leaves the oily residue you might expect from a traditional oil-based lube. You are not sacrificing easy cleanup either way.
  • Size and value: Original comes in 6 oz and 25 oz; H2O comes in 8 oz. Start with the 6 oz Original to test texture, or go straight to 25 oz if you already know you love cream.

Product facts

  • Boy Butter Water Soluble Oil-Based Glide Lube | 6 oz Tube: Boy Butter Water Soluble Oil-Based Glide Lube | 6 oz Tube is an oil-based lubricant made water-soluble, infused with Vitamin E, and engineered for marathon sessions without drying out or getting tacky. Best entry point if you want to test the creamy Original texture before buying the 25 oz bottle.
  • Boy Butter XL Oil Based Water Soluble Personal Lubricant | 25 oz Squeeze Bottle: Boy Butter XL Oil Based Water Soluble Personal Lubricant | 25 oz Squeeze Bottle is a whipped blend of coconut oil and shea butter that combines oil-based longevity with water-based cleanup. The economical choice for frequent users who already know they prefer a thick, buttery cream.
  • Boy Butter Water Based Lube with Vitamin E & Aloe Vera | 8 oz Squeeze Bottle: Boy Butter Water Based Lube with Vitamin E & Aloe Vera | 8 oz Squeeze Bottle uses Invisagel technology to mimic natural moisture with a clear, glass-like glide that stays 100% water-soluble. The right pick if you want a lightweight, transparent feel and the easiest possible cleanup.

Which Boy Butter formula fits you?

Best for

  • Anyone who wants a thick, buttery cream that lasts through marathon sessions
  • Users who dislike tacky or drying water-based lubes
  • Buyers who want a large 25 oz supply for frequent use

Not for

  • Anyone who prefers a clear, lightweight gel that mimics natural moisture
  • Users who want the smallest possible bottle for occasional use