Quick answer

Choose Boy Butter Warming Formula if you want a water-based lube that creates a gentle heat sensation, or pick Boy Butter Original for a long-lasting, oil-based glide that stays slick without warming.

Key differences in feel and ingredients

Boy Butter Warming Formula is water-based with organic coconut oil and a special warming ingredient that activates on contact—you'll feel a subtle heat as you use it. It's safe with latex, toys, and fabrics, and washes off easily. Boy Butter Original is oil-based, whipped to a creamy consistency that melts clear and stays slick longer, but it's not compatible with latex condoms (use polyurethane instead) and may require more cleanup.

Trade-offs to consider

  • Sensation: Warming Formula adds a noticeable heat that some find exciting, while Original offers a neutral, non-tingling glide.
  • Longevity: Original lasts longer without drying out, making it better for extended sessions. Warming may need reapplication as it's water-based.
  • Compatibility: Warming works with all condoms and toys. Original is not latex-safe and may degrade silicone toys. Check your condom and toy materials before choosing Original.

Product facts at a glance

  • Boy Butter Warming Formula 5 oz: Boy Butter Warming is a water-based lube with organic coconut oil and a warming ingredient; it's latex-safe, vaginally-safe, toy and fabric-safe, and washable. You get a gentle heat sensation during use without compromising safety with condoms or toys.

    Boy Butter Warming Formula 5 oz

    Boy Butter Warming Formula 5 oz

  • Boy Butter Long Lasting Personal Lubricant | Oil Based Sex Lube | 4 oz Tub: Boy Butter Original is an oil-based lube with coconut oil, whipped to a creamy texture that melts clear and delivers long-lasting glide. It provides extended slickness without reapplication, but you'll need to avoid latex condoms and expect a heavier feel.

    Boy Butter Long Lasting Personal Lubricant | Oil Based Sex Lube | 4 oz Tub

    Boy Butter Long Lasting Personal Lubricant | Oil Based Sex Lube | 4 oz Tub

Which one fits you?

Best for

  • People who want a warming sensation during intimacy
  • Those who need a water-based lube safe with latex condoms and toys

Not for

  • Anyone who prefers a neutral, non-warming lube (choose Original)
  • Users who need a long-lasting, oil-based glide without reapplication (choose Original)