Quick Answer

For everyday wear, choose Broadway Gray if you want a larger, comfortable lens with a subtle gray look. Choose Brooklyn Brown if you prefer a natural brown tone and prioritize a smaller diameter that fits more discreetly—but be aware of its smaller pupil hole.

Size and Fit: 14.5mm vs 14.2mm

Broadway Gray's 14.5mm diameter gives a slightly larger appearance, which can open up the eye and create a more noticeable enhancement. Brooklyn Brown's 14.2mm is closer to the natural iris size, making it a more subtle option for those who want a gentle color change.

The base curves also differ: Broadway Gray has an 8.8mm base curve, while Brooklyn Brown is 8.7mm. This small difference can affect how the lens sits on your eye, so consider your own eye shape and comfort preferences.

Vision Clarity: A Key Trade-off

Brooklyn Brown's catalog notes that its pupil hole is smaller than normal color lenses, which can obstruct vision when wearing it. This is a crucial consideration for anyone who needs crisp, unobstructed sight for driving, reading, or screen work.

Broadway Gray does not mention any such limitation, making it a safer choice for those who prioritize clear vision throughout the day.

Trade-offs at a Glance

  • Vision Clarity: If you need unobstructed vision for driving or screen work, choose Broadway Gray. Brooklyn Brown's smaller pupil hole may cause visual obstruction. Always prioritize vision clarity over color effect for daily wear.
  • Natural Look: Brooklyn Brown's 14.2mm diameter and brown hue offer a more subtle, natural appearance. Broadway Gray's 14.5mm gives a more noticeable enlargement. Decide whether you want a subtle or more noticeable eye enhancement.
  • Comfort and Fit: Broadway Gray's 8.8mm base curve may suit a wider range of eye shapes. Brooklyn Brown's 8.7mm base curve is slightly tighter—test for comfort. If you have sensitive eyes, consider trying the larger base curve first.

Product Facts

  • Brooklyn Brown: Brooklyn Brown has a 14.2mm diameter, 8.7mm base curve, and a smaller pupil hole that can obstruct vision. The smaller pupil hole means you might experience visual obstruction, so it's not ideal for tasks requiring sharp, clear sight.

    Brooklyn Brown

    Brooklyn Brown

  • Broadway Gray: Broadway Gray has a 14.5mm diameter and 8.8mm base curve, with no noted vision obstruction. The larger diameter and standard pupil hole provide a comfortable fit and clear vision, making it a reliable everyday option.

    Broadway Gray

    Broadway Gray

Which One Fits You?

Best For

  • Broadway Gray: Those who want a comfortable, larger lens with clear vision for all-day wear.
  • Brooklyn Brown: Those who prefer a natural brown look and don't mind a smaller pupil hole for short-term wear.

Not For

  • Brooklyn Brown: Not for anyone who needs sharp vision for driving, reading, or prolonged screen time.
  • Broadway Gray: Not for those seeking a very subtle, barely-there color change.