Quick Answer
Cartographers: Riftlands is a standalone sequel that introduces new map sheets, scoring conditions, and a focus on exploration. If you loved the original's map-drawing puzzle, Riftlands offers fresh challenges without requiring the base game. For those who prefer the classic fantasy map-building experience, the original remains a solid choice.
Cartographers
If you've ever drawn shapes to create your own fantasy map, you know the satisfying puzzle of Cartographers. The original game earned praise for its clever mix of Tetris-like placement and set collection. Now, Cartographers: Riftlands builds on that foundation with new mechanics and a fresh setting.
But is Riftlands a must-buy for fans, or should you stick with the original? This comparison breaks down the key differences, helps you decide which version fits your group, and shows how they complement each other.
What's New in Riftlands
Cartographers: Riftlands shifts the theme from peaceful map-making to defending against monsters. In the original, you compete to earn the most reputation by fulfilling scoring cards. Riftlands introduces a new type of terrain and a focus on exploration, with players drawing shapes to reveal the land while fending off threats.
The most noticeable change is the map sheets. Riftlands uses different map layouts and scoring conditions, which alter your strategic priorities. For example, you might need to balance placing terrain to maximize points while also preparing for monster attacks. This adds a layer of tension that the original lacks.
- Riftlands is a standalone game, so you don't need the original to play.
- The new map sheets and scoring cards create a different puzzle each game.
Comparing Gameplay Mechanics
Both games share the core loop: draw a shape, place it on your map, and score points based on the current scoring card. However, Riftlands introduces a combat element. Players must gather information about a monstrous threat and prepare for a showdown. This means you might need to sacrifice short-term points to position yourself for a better endgame.
The original Cartographers is more relaxed, focusing purely on map-building and maximizing reputation. If you enjoy a pure optimization puzzle, the original might suit you better. If you want more interaction and a sense of urgency, Riftlands adds that without making the game overly complex.
- Riftlands adds a monster-fighting layer, while the original is purely about map scoring.
- Both games support solo and multiplayer, but Riftlands' combat can feel more thematic.
Content and Replayability
Cartographers: Riftlands comes with new map sheets and scoring cards, offering a different experience from the original. The game also includes multiple scenarios, each with unique rules and objectives, which increases replayability. If you've played the original to death, Riftlands provides fresh challenges.
However, the original Cartographers has a large ecosystem of expansions and map packs, like the Cartographers: Extra Map Sheets. These let you customize your games with different maps and challenges. Riftlands is newer, so its expansion library is smaller, but it already has its own map packs available.
- Riftlands includes multiple scenarios for varied play.
- Original Cartographers has more expansions currently available.
Trade-offs to Consider
- New mechanics vs. familiar simplicity: Riftlands adds combat and information-gathering, which can be exciting but also adds complexity. The original is simpler and more straightforward. If you want a fresh challenge, Riftlands is worth it; if you prefer pure map-building, stick with the original.
- Standalone vs. expansion support: Riftlands is a standalone game, so you don't need the original. However, the original has a larger library of expansions and map packs. Consider whether you value a new experience over a growing ecosystem.
- Theme and atmosphere: Riftlands has a more adversarial tone with monsters, while the original feels more peaceful. The theme affects how the game feels. Choose based on your group's preference for competitive or relaxed play.
Products Mentioned
- Cartographers Heroes: Fight back against monsters as you draw shapes to create your own fantasy map. The stand-alone sequel to the critically acclaimed map-drawing game, Cartographers. Cartographers Heroes is a standalone sequel that introduces a monster-fighting theme, similar to Riftlands but with its own unique map and rules. If you want another take on the formula, this is a great addition.
- Cartographers: Extra Map Sheets A1/A1 (Affril): Run out of Map Sheets for Cartographers Map Pack 2 (Affril)? Grab some extras! Pad of 75 sheets. Double-sided with A1 and A2 sides. If you play frequently, extra map sheets are a practical way to keep the game going without buying a new copy. They are compatible with specific map packs, so check which pack you have.
Which One Should You Choose?
Best for
- Players who want a fresh twist on the map-drawing formula
- Groups that enjoy a bit of conflict and preparation mechanics
Not for
- Purists who love the original's simple optimization puzzle
- Those who already own many Cartographers expansions and prefer to keep using them
Both Cartographers and Riftlands offer rewarding map-drawing experiences, but they cater to slightly different tastes. If you're ready for a new challenge with added depth, Riftlands is an excellent choice. If you prefer the classic puzzle and want to expand your collection with existing content, the original remains a great game. Either way, you'll enjoy the creative satisfaction of building your own fantasy world.
