Quick answer
Choose the PlanToys Clatter for toddlers 18 months and up who need a first, space-saving rhythm toy; choose the Drum Set for older kids ready for a full band experience with multiple percussion sounds.
Age and motor skill fit
The Clatter is designed for children 18 months and older, making it a natural first instrument. Its alternating up-and-down motion is simple enough for little hands and helps build fine motor skills while encouraging creative expression.
The Drum Set is a more complex instrument that requires hand-eye coordination and the ability to use a kick pedal. It suits preschoolers and early elementary kids who can handle multiple parts and want to explore different rhythms.
Sound variety and play value
The Drum Set is the first in the world to be entirely made of wood and includes a snare drum, tom drum, bass drum with kick pedal, cymbal, and rubber drum sticks. This gives children a wide range of sounds and rhythms to experiment with, making it ideal for creative play and even pretend performances.
The Clatter produces click-clack sounds when manipulated, offering a more limited but still engaging auditory experience. It's perfect for younger children who are just discovering cause and effect.
Space and budget considerations
The Drum Set is a full-sized playset that requires floor space and a higher investment (catalog price USD 197.99). The Clatter is compact, portable, and more affordable (USD 17.99), making it a practical choice for small homes or travel.
Consider your available play area and how much you want to invest in a first music toy. The Clatter is a low-commitment option, while the Drum Set is a statement piece for a dedicated playroom.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Age range: Clatter is for 18 months and up; Drum Set suits older preschoolers and early elementary kids. Match the toy to your child's current motor skills and attention span.
- Sound variety: Drum Set offers multiple drum types and a cymbal for diverse rhythms; Clatter provides click-clack sounds only. If your child craves variety, the Drum Set wins; for simpler exploration, the Clatter suffices.
- Space and price: Drum Set is a large, pricier playset (USD 197.99); Clatter is compact and budget-friendly (USD 17.99). Measure your play area and set a budget before deciding.
Product facts
-
Drum Set: The Drum Set is the first in the world to be entirely made out of wood and includes a snare drum, tom drum, bass drum with kick pedal, cymbal, and rubber drum sticks. This gives children a full range of sounds and rhythms to explore, supporting hand-eye coordination and motor skills through active play.
Drum Set
-
Clatter: The Clatter is suitable for children 18 months and older and produces various click-clack sounds when manipulated with an alternating up-and-down motion. It's a safe, simple first instrument that improves fine motor skills and encourages creative expression without needing much space.
Clatter
Which one fits your child?
Best for
- Toddlers 18 months to 3 years who are just starting to explore rhythm and cause and effect
- Families with limited space or a tight budget who still want a quality wooden music toy
Not for
- Older children (4+) who want a full band experience and multiple percussion sounds—consider the Drum Set instead
- Parents seeking a quiet, low-stimulation toy—both toys produce noticeable sounds, but the Drum Set is louder and more complex
