Cloth Trainer vs Diaper: What's the Real Difference?
If you're in the middle of potty training, you've probably wondered whether a cloth trainer is just a fancy diaper or something genuinely different. The short answer: a cloth trainer is designed to let your toddler feel wetness while still containing messes, which is a key step in the transition to underwear. A diaper, on the other hand, wicks moisture away and can make it harder for a child to recognize the urge to go.
The Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style) from Squishy Lil' Campers is a good example of what a cloth trainer offers. Unlike a disposable diaper, it has a wide front and back elastic that makes it easy for little ones to pull up and down on their own—a skill they'll need for underwear. It also comes with snaps and an opening to add extra absorbency if needed, giving you flexibility as your child's needs change.
Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style) at a Glance
-
Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style): These are our new and improved trainers that now have snaps and an opening to add extra absorbency if needed. They are lined with bamboo terry, come pre-padded with 3 layers of bamboo and they have a wide front and back elastic making it easy for those littles to still pull up and down. The snaps and opening let you adjust absorbency for different stages of potty training, while the elastic waistband encourages independence.
Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style)
-
Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style): These fit roughly 12-50lbs This wide weight range means the trainer can grow with your child through much of the potty training journey, reducing the need to buy multiple sizes.
When to Choose a Cloth Trainer Over a Diaper
The decision often comes down to your child's readiness and your potty training approach. Here's how the Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style) compares to a standard diaper in key areas.
- Independence: The wide front and back elastic on the Pigged This trainer lets toddlers pull it up and down by themselves. Diapers typically require lying down and fastening, which doesn't build the muscle memory for underwear.
- Wetness Awareness: Cloth trainers like this one are less absorbent than a diaper, so your child feels wetness sooner. This feedback helps them connect the sensation with the need to use the potty. Disposable diapers are designed to keep skin dry, which can delay that connection.
- Absorbency Options: The Pigged This trainer comes pre-padded with 3 layers of bamboo and has an opening to add more absorbency if needed. This means you can use it for naps or outings without switching to a diaper. Standard diapers have fixed absorbency.
- Cost and Reusability: This cloth trainer is reusable, making it more economical over time compared to disposable diapers or pull-ups. The catalog price is USD 7.68 (compared to USD 12.00), and it fits from 12 to 50 lbs, so one trainer can serve for months.
What the Product Information Does Not Tell You
The supplied record confirms the Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style) has snaps, bamboo terry lining, and a wide elastic waistband, but it does not include specific care instructions or details about how the absorbency performs for heavy wetters. If your child is a heavy wetter, you may want to test the trainer at home first before relying on it for outings. The opening for extra absorbency gives you a way to boost performance, but the record does not specify what type of booster fits or how much to add.
Also, while the trainer is designed for pull-up ease, the record does not describe the fit around the legs. Some children may experience gaps if the legs are very chunky or very slim. As with any cloth product, checking the fit after the first wash is a good idea.
Making the Switch
There's no single right age to switch from diapers to a cloth trainer, but many parents start when their child shows signs of potty readiness—staying dry for longer periods, showing interest in the toilet, or being able to follow simple instructions. The Pigged This-Cloth Trainer (old style) is a practical middle ground: it gives your toddler the independence of pull-up pants with the reusability and wetness feedback of cloth. If you're already using cloth diapers, this trainer fits naturally into your routine. If you're coming from disposables, the snaps and bamboo padding make it a familiar-feeling step toward underwear.



