Quick answer
If you want a compact, budget-friendly expansion that adds new cases and keeps the core tension, go with Saints & Sinners. If you're ready for a bigger, cinematic Hollywood-themed campaign with more content, Bullets Over Hollywood is the richer investment.
What each expansion brings
Detective: Saints & Sinners is the latest expansion for Detective: City of Angels, set in gritty 1940s Los Angeles. It adds new cases and content that slot directly into the base game, giving returning detectives fresh mysteries without overhauling how you play.
Detective: Bullets Over Hollywood is an epic narrative-driven expansion that leans into the dark, violent world of 1940s Hollywood. It introduces four new cases, making it a more substantial addition for groups that want a longer campaign arc.
The trade-off: depth vs. size
Saints & Sinners is the leaner pick. It's priced lower, so it's an easy next step if you're still getting comfortable with the base game or want to test a new case without a big commitment. Because it's the latest expansion, it also reflects the most recent design ideas for the system.
Bullets Over Hollywood is the bigger swing. With four cases, it offers more replay mileage, but it costs more and asks for a longer time investment. If your group plays regularly and wants a Hollywood-flavored storyline, the extra content justifies the price.
Which expansion should you choose?
- Budget and commitment: If you want a lower-cost expansion that still delivers new cases, Saints & Sinners is the smarter buy. If you're willing to spend more for a bigger campaign, Bullets Over Hollywood gives you four cases for more replay value. Check your group's play frequency before deciding.
- Theme preference: Saints & Sinners keeps the gritty 1940s LA vibe. Bullets Over Hollywood leans into the dark and violent world of Hollywood, which may appeal if you want a more cinematic, star-studded mystery. Match the theme to what your group finds most immersive.
- Content completeness: Saints & Sinners does not include the discontinued Cloak & Daggered case. If that case is a must-have, you'll need to find it separately or choose Bullets Over Hollywood, which includes four full cases. Confirm which cases are included before you buy.
Expansion facts at a glance
-
Detective: Bullets Over Hollywood: Detective: Bullets Over Hollywood is an epic narrative-driven expansion set in the dark and violent world of 1940s Los Angeles, adding four cases. If you want a longer campaign with a cinematic Hollywood theme, this expansion gives you more content to sink your teeth into.
Detective: Bullets Over Hollywood
-
Detective: Saints & Sinners (No Cloak & Daggered): Detective: Saints & Sinners is the latest expansion for Detective: City of Angels, set in gritty 1940s Los Angeles, and does not include the discontinued Cloak & Daggered case. It's a more budget-friendly way to expand your game, but note that the Cloak & Daggered case is not included, so if you specifically want that case, you'll need to look elsewhere.
Detective: Saints & Sinners (No Cloak & Daggered)
Who should buy which?
Best for
- Budget-conscious players who want a solid expansion without a big price tag: Saints & Sinners
- Groups that play regularly and want a longer, cinematic campaign: Bullets Over Hollywood
Not for
- Players who specifically want the Cloak & Daggered case – Saints & Sinners won't include it
- Those who prefer short, one-session cases – Bullets Over Hollywood's four-case arc may be too long
