Quick answer

For a compact desk or bedside table, the Echo Show 5 offers just enough screen and sound at a lower price. If you want a larger display for video calls or streaming, the Echo Show 8 is the better pick.

Screen size and desk space

The Echo Show 5 has a 5.5-inch screen, which is ideal for tight spaces like a small desk, nightstand, or kitchen counter. It shows the time, weather, and notifications without dominating your workspace. The Echo Show 8 features a larger 8-inch display, making it easier to see video calls, watch recipes, or follow along with workouts, but it takes up more room.

Sound quality and media use

If you plan to stream music or podcasts while you work, the Echo Show 5 delivers clearer sound with 2x the bass compared to earlier models, making it a solid choice for a small room. The Echo Show 8 generally offers fuller audio, but if you're just listening to background music at your desk, the Echo Show 5's improved sound is often enough.

Privacy and control features

Both displays let you control smart home devices like lights and thermostats, and both include a mic and camera off button for privacy. The Echo Show 5's built-in camera can be used for video calls and to check in on your home, but you can easily cover it when not in use. For a desk, the smaller footprint and privacy controls make the Echo Show 5 a practical option.

How to decide: trade-offs at a glance

  • Desk space: If your desk is small or cluttered, the Echo Show 5's 5.5-inch screen fits neatly without crowding your workspace. The Echo Show 8's larger display requires more room.
  • Video calls and media: For frequent video calls or watching videos while you work, the Echo Show 8's bigger screen is easier to see. If you only glance at the screen occasionally, the Echo Show 5 is sufficient.
  • Budget: The Echo Show 5 is priced at $44.99, offering a lower entry point. If you need the larger screen, expect to pay more for the Echo Show 8. Consider how often you'll use the screen for calls or media before spending extra.

Product facts

Which one should you choose?

Best for

  • Compact desks or nightstands where space is limited
  • Budget-conscious shoppers who want a capable smart display

Not for

  • Users who primarily want a large screen for video calls or watching content
  • Those who need a display that can be easily read from across a room