Quick answer
The second edition is the definitive version for most players, adding ports, garrisons, and refined rules that fix pacing issues from the original. Stick with the first edition only if you prefer a simpler, faster game or already own expansions built for it.
What the second edition adds
The second edition incorporates elements from the original expansion, including ports that allow naval movement around the coast and garrisons that give each stronghold a small defensive force. These additions reduce the advantage of first-turn blitzes and make coastal territories more strategic.
The updated rulebook also clarifies ambiguous edge cases from the first edition, such as tie-breaking in combat and order placement restrictions. If your group spent time arguing over rules, the second edition will save you that hassle.
What you lose with the second edition
The first edition is leaner and plays faster, especially with fewer than six players. The second edition's extra components and rules add about 20-30 minutes to a typical game, which matters if your group prefers a shorter session.
If you already own the first edition and its expansion, upgrading to the second edition means those expansions are not compatible. You would need to buy the second edition expansion separately.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Ports and naval movement: Second edition adds ports, allowing ships to move along the coast without entering open sea. This makes naval strategy more nuanced and coastal territories more valuable.
- Garrisons for strongholds: Each stronghold now starts with a garrison token that acts as a free defender. This slows down early rushes and gives the defending player a better chance to hold key positions.
- Streamlined combat and tie-breaking: The second edition clarifies how ties are resolved and how order tokens interact. Fewer rule disputes mean less downtime during the game. If your group often argues over rules, the second edition is the smoother choice.
Product facts
-
A Game of Thrones Boardgame 2nd Edition: The second edition is based on the best-selling novel series A Song of Ice and Fire and lets 3-6 players take control of the great houses of Westeros. It supports the same player count as the first edition but with refined rules that make the game more balanced and less prone to early elimination.
A Game of Thrones Boardgame 2nd Edition
Which edition fits you?
Best for
- Groups new to the game who want the most polished ruleset
- Players who value balanced naval combat and defensive options
- Anyone who dislikes rule ambiguity and wants a clear rulebook
Not for
- Players who already own the first edition and its expansion and do not want to reinvest
- Groups that prefer a shorter, simpler game without extra components
