Quick Answer

Choose your gel polish shade based on your skin tone, the occasion, and the mood you want to create. Forest Floor offers a deep emerald cat eye, Fudge Pop is a rich red-toned brown, and XOXO is a soft baby pink—each suits different styles and settings.

Why Undertones Matter

When selecting a gel polish color, the undertone can change how the shade looks on your nails. Warm undertones (yellow, gold, or red) tend to complement warmer skin tones, while cool undertones (blue, pink, or green) flatter cooler skin tones. Forest Floor's garden emerald has a cool green base, Fudge Pop's red undertones add warmth, and XOXO's baby pink is neutral with a hint of cool.

Consider the occasion: deep, moody shades like Forest Floor work well for evening events or autumn, while soft pinks like XOXO are perfect for everyday wear or spring. Fudge Pop's warm brown is versatile for both casual and formal settings.

Finish and Formula Considerations

The finish of a gel polish—whether cat eye, cream, or glossy—affects the final look. Forest Floor is a cat eye shade, which creates a shimmering, metallic effect that catches light. Fudge Pop and XOXO have a classic creamy formula with extreme pigment and anti-spread properties, making them easy to apply for solid, opaque coverage.

If you enjoy nail art or want a simple French tip, the anti-spread formula in Fudge Pop and XOXO helps keep lines crisp. For a more dramatic, dimensional look, the cat eye effect of Forest Floor adds depth without extra effort.

Decision Rules for Choosing Your Shade

  • Skin Tone Match: If you have warm undertones, choose Fudge Pop for its red undertones. If you have cool undertones, Forest Floor's green or XOXO's pink will complement you better. Test the shade against your skin before buying if possible.
  • Occasion and Mood: For a bold, evening look, choose Forest Floor's deep emerald cat eye. For a soft, everyday feel, pick XOXO's baby pink. Fudge Pop works for both casual and formal settings.
  • Finish Preference: If you want a shimmering effect, go with Forest Floor. If you prefer a classic, creamy finish, choose Fudge Pop or XOXO. Consider how the finish will look with your nail length and shape.
  • Application Ease: All three have anti-spread formulas, but the creamy body of Fudge Pop and XOXO is especially forgiving for beginners. Forest Floor's cat eye requires a magnet for the effect, so it's a bit more advanced. If you're new to gel polish, start with a creamy shade.

Product Facts

  • Forest Floor - Gel Polish: Forest Floor is a garden emerald velvet cat eye gel polish, HEMA and TPO free, with an anti-spread, creamy body. The cat eye finish creates a shimmering, dimensional look, while the HEMA and TPO free formula is a plus for those with sensitivities.

    Forest Floor - Gel Polish

    Forest Floor - Gel Polish

  • Fudge Pop - Gel Polish: Fudge Pop is a deep 3 shade with red undertones, part of a classic creamy gel formula with extreme pigment and anti-spread. The red undertones add warmth, making it a flattering choice for many skin tones, and the anti-spread formula ensures precise application.

    Fudge Pop - Gel Polish

    Fudge Pop - Gel Polish

  • XOXO - Gel Polish: XOXO is a soak-off gel polish in a perfect baby pink shade, compatible with UV and LED curing, with a classic creamy formula and extreme pigment. Its baby pink hue is versatile and universally flattering, and the soak-off formula makes removal easier at home.

Who Should Choose Which

Best For

  • Forest Floor: Those who love bold, moody colors and want a shimmering cat eye effect.
  • Fudge Pop: Those with warm skin tones or who want a versatile, earthy brown for any occasion.
  • XOXO: Those who prefer a soft, feminine pink that works for everyday wear or bridal looks.

Not For

  • Forest Floor: Those who prefer subtle, neutral shades or dislike metallic finishes.
  • Fudge Pop: Those who want a cool-toned or very light polish.
  • XOXO: Those who want a bold, dramatic color or a dark shade.