Quick answer
If you're unsure which hay your pet prefers, the Sampler Hay Box gives you four types to try. If your pet is a picky eater, the Gourmet Hay can add variety. New adopters can get a free 2lb box of hay with a rescue code.
Why variety matters in a hay diet
Small pets naturally eat a wide variety of grasses in the wild. Offering different hay types can prevent boredom and encourage consistent fiber intake. Each hay type has a distinct texture and taste, so rotating them can keep mealtime interesting.
Sampler Hay Box vs Gourmet Hay: What's the difference?
The Sampler Hay Box includes 2 lbs each of 2nd cutting Timothy, 3rd cutting Timothy, Oat hay, and Orchard hay. It is designed for pet owners who want to test multiple hays without committing to a large bag. The Gourmet Hay is a single product meant to perk up a pet's appetite, either on its own or mixed with regular hay. If your goal is to discover a new favorite, the sampler is the better choice. If you need a quick appetite booster, the gourmet hay works well.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Sampler Hay Box: Best for discovering which hay your pet prefers. You get four types in one box, but you pay for variety rather than a single large bag. Great first purchase for new pet owners.
- Gourmet Hay: Targeted appetite booster. It adds novelty to a regular diet but is a single product, so you won't get multiple hay types. Use as a supplement, not a complete replacement.
- Orchard Hay (standalone): A single-type hay that is gentle on allergies and provides variety. It lacks the mix of textures found in the sampler. Ideal if you already know your pet likes Orchard hay.
- Adopter's Gift - 2lb Box: Free for adopters using a rescue code. You choose the hay type, but the offer is limited to one box per adopter. Claim it if you recently adopted a pet.
Product facts at a glance
-
Sampler Hay Box: Contains 2 lbs each of 2nd cutting Timothy, 3rd cutting Timothy, Oat hay, and Orchard hay. You can compare four textures and flavors side by side to find what your pet loves most.
Sampler Hay Box
-
Gourmet Hay: Designed to perk up your animal's hay appetite and can be served alone or mixed with regular hay. Ideal for picky eaters who need a little encouragement to eat enough fiber.
Gourmet Hay
-
Orchard Hay: Orchard hay is a nice change and is also terrific for owners with Timothy hay allergies. If you or your pet react to Timothy, Orchard hay provides a safe alternative while still offering essential fiber.
-
Adopter's Gift - 2lb Box of Hay: Free 2lb box of hay of your choice for adopters who use a personal code from a rescue partner. New adopters can try a hay type at no cost, making the transition easier for both pet and owner.
Which hay box fits your situation?
Best for
- New pet owners who want to test multiple hay types
- Owners of picky eaters who need an appetite boost
- Adopters looking for a free starter box
Not for
- Owners who already know their pet's favorite hay and want a large bulk bag
- Owners who need a single hay type for allergy management (choose standalone Orchard hay instead)
