Quick answer

For a structured, performance-ready fit, choose the Hickory Crawdads New Era Batting Practice 59Fifty Fitted Cap. If you prefer an easy, relaxed fit with a vintage look, go with the '47 Red Cleanup American Flag Heritage Adjustable Hat. For a classic adjustable with a snapback closure, the '47 Overhand Hitch Adjustable Cap is a solid middle ground.

Fitted vs Adjustable vs Snapback: What's the Difference?

Fitted caps, like the Hickory Crawdads New Era 59Fifty, are sized to your exact head measurement. They offer a structured fit, high crown, and flat bill that you can curve. Because they come in specific sizes, you need to know your size before buying.

Adjustable caps use a buckle or strap to fit a range of head sizes. The '47 Red Cleanup Heritage Hat features an unstructured relaxed fit with a low crown and curved bill, giving it a broken-in, vintage feel. It's a great choice if you share hats or want a looser fit.

Snapback caps are a type of adjustable that uses a plastic snap closure. The '47 Overhand Hitch Adjustable Cap uses a plastic snapback, offering a relaxed fit and curved brim. It combines the convenience of adjustability with a slightly more structured look than a buckle-back hat.

How to Choose the Right Fit

Start by measuring your head circumference just above your ears. Use that measurement to find your fitted cap size. If you're between sizes or prefer a looser feel, an adjustable or snapback cap gives you more flexibility.

Consider the crown height. Fitted caps typically have a high crown, which suits longer faces or those who like a taller silhouette. Adjustable caps often have a low crown, which can look more balanced on round or oval faces.

Think about the bill shape. The 59Fifty has a flat bill that you can curve to your liking. The '47 adjustable hats come with a pre-curved bill, so you get that classic baseball look right out of the box.

Tradeoffs at a Glance

  • Fitted (59Fifty): Requires exact sizing; structured high crown; flat bill you can curve; performance polyester. Best for a precise, sporty fit. Great if you know your size and want a cap that stays put during activity.
  • Adjustable Buckle ('47 Heritage): One-size-fits-most with buckle closure; unstructured low crown; pre-curved bill; garment-washed cotton. Best for a relaxed, vintage vibe. Perfect for casual wear and sharing, but lacks the structure for high-intensity use.
  • Snapback ('47 Overhand Hitch): Plastic snap closure; relaxed fit; curved brim; raised embroidery on front. A middle ground between fitted and buckle-back adjustability. Offers easy adjustability with a slightly more structured look than a buckle cap.

Cap Features at a Glance

  • Hickory Crawdads New Era Batting Practice 59Fifty Fitted Cap: Official batting practice hat. Material: 100% Performance Polyester. Brand: New Era. Fit: Structured fit. Flat bill with ability to curve. High Crown. Raised embroidery. Six panels with eyelets. The structured fit and performance polyester make this cap ideal for active wear or hot days. The flat bill gives you the option to shape it exactly how you want.
  • Hickory Crawdads '47 Red Cleanup American Flag Heritage Adjustable Hat: Flat embroidered American flag patch above right ear. Embroidered front logo with raised details. Unstructured relaxed fit. Low crown. Buckle closure. Garment washed cotton twill. Curved bill. Brand: '47 Brand. The unstructured relaxed fit and garment-washed cotton twill give this hat a soft, lived-in feel from day one. The low crown and curved bill create a classic, understated look that pairs well with casual outfits.

Which Cap Style Fits You?

Best for

  • Fans who want a precise, performance-oriented fit for games or workouts
  • Those who prefer a low-maintenance, one-size-fits-most cap with a vintage look
  • Anyone who shares hats or wants a classic adjustable with a snap closure

Not for

  • If you dislike flat bills or need a cap that fits without measuring, skip the fitted 59Fifty
  • If you need a structured cap that holds its shape during physical activity, the unstructured '47 Heritage may feel too loose