Quick Answer
Measure your head circumference just above your eyebrows and ears, then match it to the New Era 59Fifty size chart—your Crawdads fitted cap should feel snug but not tight, with no gaps and no pressure points.
Why Fitted Caps Fit Differently
Unlike adjustable caps, a fitted 59Fifty has no strap or buckle to tweak—the size is built into the crown and band. That means getting the measurement right matters more. The structured fit and flat bill are designed to hold their shape, so a cap that's too loose will look slouchy, and one that's too tight can cause headaches.
New Era 59Fifty caps are sized in eighths of an inch (e.g., 7 1/8, 7 1/4). If you're between sizes, most wearers prefer the slightly larger size, because you can add a bit of padding or use a hat stretcher, but you can't make a too-small cap comfortable.
How to Measure Your Head for a Fitted Cap
Use a flexible measuring tape or a piece of string. Place it around your head about 1/8 inch above your ear and across the middle of your forehead—this is the standard position for fitted caps. Keep the tape snug but not tight, and note the measurement in inches.
Compare your measurement to the New Era size chart: for example, 22 1/8 inches corresponds to size 7 1/8, 22 1/2 to 7 1/4, and so on. If you don't have a tape, you can use a string and a ruler.
Trade-Offs: High Crown and Structured Fit
The 59Fifty is a high-crown cap, which means it sits taller on your head than a low-profile cap. This style suits many face shapes but can feel overwhelming if you have a smaller head. The structured fit keeps the front panels stiff, so the cap won't collapse—good for a clean look, but it also means the cap won't 'break in' as much as a softer cap.
If you prefer a curved brim, note that the 59Fifty's flat bill can be curved, but it takes some effort. The material is 100% performance polyester, which is lightweight and moisture-wicking, but it's not as breathable as natural fibers in hot weather.
Decision Rules for 59Fifty Sizing
- Measure your head: Use a tape measure around your head at the standard fitted-cap position (just above ears and across the forehead). Write down the inches. Measure twice to avoid ordering the wrong size.
- Match to the size chart: Convert your measurement to the nearest 1/8 inch size (e.g., 22 1/8 → 7 1/8). If you're between sizes, choose the larger one.
- Check the fit: The cap should feel snug with no gaps and no pressure points. If it leaves red marks after a few minutes, it's too tight. If it's slightly loose, use a hat size adjuster strip or a hat stretcher.
- Consider the high crown: If you have a smaller head or prefer a lower profile, the 59Fifty's high crown may feel too tall. In that case, look for a low-profile fitted option.
Product Facts
-
Hickory Crawdads New Era Hickory Dickory Docks 59Fifty Fitted Cap: The Hickory Dickory Docks 59Fifty is made of 100% Performance Polyester and features a structured fit with a flat bill that can be curved. This cap's structured fit holds its shape, so accurate sizing is crucial—if it's too loose, it won't self-correct.
Hickory Crawdads New Era Hickory Dickory Docks 59Fifty Fitted Cap
-
Hickory Crawdads 2026 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap: The Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty also uses 100% Performance Polyester, with a structured fit, high crown, and raised embroidery on six panels. The raised embroidery adds thickness to the front panels, which can affect how the cap sits—consider sizing up if you prefer a looser fit.
Hickory Crawdads 2026 New Era Llamas de Hickory 59Fifty Fitted Cap
Who Should Choose a 59Fifty Fitted Cap
Best for
- Fans who want a clean, sporty look with no adjustable strap in the back
- Collectors who appreciate the classic New Era fitted silhouette and structured crown
Not for
- People who prefer a one-size-fits-most adjustable cap for quick, flexible fit
- Those who like a low-profile cap that sits closer to the head
