Quick answer
Choose a cigar ashtray that has a deep bowl or a rest that holds your cigar securely, is made of a durable material like ceramic or metal, and matches the size of your smoking area. Avoid shallow ashtrays that let ash blow away or cigars roll off.
Why ashtray depth and bowl design matter
A cigar produces more ash than a cigarette, so a shallow ashtray will fill quickly and spill ash onto your table. A deep bowl, like the one found in the Stinky ashtray line, keeps ash contained even in a light breeze. The bowl also helps extinguish a cigar butt safely without leaving a mess.
Material and weight considerations
Ceramic and metal ashtrays are the most common choices for cigar smokers. Ceramic is heavy enough to stay put on a table and resists heat well. Metal can be lighter and easier to clean, but may heat up if you rest a lit cigar on it for long. Consider where you will use the ashtray—on a desk, patio, or beside an armchair—and choose a weight that won't tip over easily.
Steps to choose your cigar ashtray
- 1. Decide where you will smoke most often: Indoor smokers need a stable base that won't scratch surfaces; outdoor smokers need wind resistance and weight. A tall ashtray like the Stinky Tall works well on a table or patio because its height makes it hard to knock over. Common mistake: buying a lightweight ashtray for outdoor use—it will tip over in a breeze.
- 2. Pick a material that suits your habits: Ceramic is classic and heat-resistant; metal is easy to clean but can get hot. If you often set down a lit cigar, ceramic is safer. If you clean frequently, metal is easier. Checkpoint: run your hand over the rim—sharp edges can snag or chip.
- 3. Check the rest or notch design: Look for a deep V-cut or a pair of notches that hold a cigar securely at a 45-degree angle. This keeps the ash from falling off and the cigar from rolling away. Some ashtrays have a single rest; others have multiple for sharing. Common mistake: assuming all notches fit a thick ring gauge cigar—test with your favorite size if possible.
- 4. Confirm the bowl depth: A deep bowl (at least 1.5 inches) holds more ash and prevents ash from blowing around. Shallow bowls fill quickly and require frequent emptying. The Stinky ashtray's deep bowl is a good benchmark. Checkpoint: if the bowl is less than 1 inch deep, it is designed for cigarettes, not cigars.
- 5. Match the size to your smoking area: A large ashtray on a small side table can feel cramped; a small ashtray on a big table can look lost. Measure your table space and choose an ashtray that leaves room for a drink, lighter, and cutter. Common mistake: buying an ashtray that is too large for the table—it becomes a hazard instead of an accessory.
Product spotlight
-
Ashtray Stinky Tall: The Ashtray Stinky Tall Cherry Black is a taller Stinky cigar ashtray with a cherry and black look. The taller format gives it more presence on a table while keeping the practical deep-bowl feel Stinky ashtrays are known for. This means you get a stable, eye-catching ashtray that holds plenty of ash and keeps your cigar secure, ideal for a dedicated smoking spot.
Ashtray Stinky Tall
