Quick answer
Choose I'll Be Home if you want a deep blue matte-velvet look that's opaque in one coat. Pick It's Alive for a buildable pearly metallic sheen that needs 2–3 coats and a glossy top coat for maximum shine.
Finish and opacity: the main difference
The biggest difference between these two Lights Lacquer polishes is how they look and apply. I'll Be Home has a velvet finish that dries matte, giving nails a soft, suede-like texture with a subtle shimmer. It's opaque, so one coat can cover the nail. It's Alive is a metallic polish with a buildable sheer formula. You'll need 2–3 layers to achieve that mirror-like sheen, and it pairs best with a glossy top coat for extra shine.
Wear and maintenance
Because I'll Be Home dries matte, it may show wear differently than a glossy metallic. Matte finishes can chip less visibly but may need a top coat if you want gloss. It's Alive is self-leveling and easy to remove, but its sheer formula means touch-ups on a single nail might be more noticeable if you don't reapply all layers.
Trade-offs to consider
- I'll Be Home: opaque matte velvet: One-coat coverage with a soft, matte finish. No need for a top coat unless you want gloss.
- It's Alive: buildable sheer metallic: Requires 2–3 coats for full opacity. A glossy top coat is recommended for maximum shine.
- Texture and feel: I'll Be Home has a velvety, matte texture. It's Alive has a smooth, glossy finish when paired with a top coat. If you dislike the feel of matte polish, choose It's Alive with a top coat.
Product facts at a glance
-
I'll Be Home: Deep blue polish with a velvet finish that dries matte; opaque in nature. You get full coverage in one coat and a soft, non-shiny texture that feels like suede.
I'll Be Home
-
It's Alive!: Pearly silver metallic finish; buildable sheer, can be layered in 2–3 coats for a mirror-like sheen; best paired with a glossy top coat. You control the intensity, and adding a glossy top coat gives you that high-shine metallic look.
It's Alive!
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Someone who wants a deep blue nail with a unique matte-velvet texture and one-coat coverage
- Anyone who prefers a subtle shimmer without high shine
Not ideal for
- Those who want a high-gloss metallic finish without extra steps
- Anyone who dislikes matte textures or wants a sheer, buildable look
