Quick answer

If you want a slim, clear case that shows off your iPhone 17 and works seamlessly with MagSafe accessories, go with the COVERT. If you need heavy-duty drop protection and a premium metal feel, the ATOMIC aluminum case is the better choice.

Clear vs. Aluminum: What Each Case Offers

The COVERT case is a protective clear MagSafe case that keeps your phone's design visible. It comes in several finishes, including Smoke and Clear Matte, and includes a screen protector, 45W USB-C wall charger, and 60W USB-C charging cable in the box. This makes it a complete package for everyday use without extra purchases.

The ATOMIC case is built around an aluminum frame for a sturdy, premium feel. It is designed specifically for iPhone 17 Pro and Pro Max models and is MagSafe-ready, so you can attach chargers and wallets without removing the case. The aluminum construction adds weight and rigidity, offering more robust protection against drops and impacts.

MagSafe Compatibility and Accessories

Both cases support MagSafe, but the experience differs. The COVERT's clear back allows you to see the phone's original color while using magnetic accessories. The ATOMIC's aluminum frame provides a stronger magnetic hold due to the metal construction, which can be more secure for heavier accessories like battery packs.

Trade-offs to consider

  • Protection level: The ATOMIC's aluminum frame offers more structural rigidity than the COVERT's clear polycarbonate. If you drop your phone frequently, the ATOMIC provides better shock absorption. ATOMIC wins for drop protection.
  • Weight and feel: The COVERT is lighter and slimmer, making it easier to slide into pockets. The ATOMIC is heavier due to the metal frame, which some users find more reassuring but others find bulky. COVERT is better for everyday carry.
  • Included accessories: The COVERT comes with a screen protector, wall charger, and cable. The ATOMIC does not include these extras, so you may need to purchase them separately. COVERT offers better value out of the box.

Product facts at a glance

iPhone 17 / Air Series Protective Clear MagSafe Cases — COVERT

iPhone 17 / Air Series Protective Clear MagSafe Cases — COVERT

  • iPhone 17 Pro / Max Aluminum MagSafe Cases — ATOMIC: iPhone 17 Pro / Max Aluminum MagSafe Cases — ATOMIC The aluminum frame gives this case a premium, rigid feel and extra impact resistance. It is ideal if you prioritize drop protection over showing off the phone's original color.

Which case fits you?

Best for

  • Users who want a lightweight, clear case that shows off their iPhone 17 and includes essential accessories
  • Those who prioritize MagSafe accessory compatibility with a secure magnetic hold

Not for

  • Users who need maximum drop protection and prefer a metal frame
  • Anyone who dislikes the added weight of an aluminum case