Two decaf black teas, two different evening moods
Mistletoe Tea and Decaf Black Cream both come from Clipper Ship Tea Company's decaf black tea range, but they are built for different moments. One is a limited-edition holiday blend with cinnamon, mint, chocolate, and vanilla; the other is a year-round cream-flavored black tea that mimics a traditional English Breakfast with milk and sugar. Neither is completely caffeine-free—both use CO2 decaffeination, which leaves a very slight caffeine residue—so if you need zero caffeine, look to the company's herbal, rooibos, honeybush, or fruit tisane options instead.
This comparison sticks to what the catalog confirms: ingredients, tasting notes, steep directions, and available sizes. Where the catalog is silent—such as whether either tea is allergen-free or how long an opened bag stays fresh—we flag that as a limitation rather than guess.
Flavor and ingredients side by side
- Mistletoe Tea: Tasting notes: cinnamon + mint with sweetness. Ingredients: decaffeinated black tea, cinnamon, chocolate, peppermint, vanilla, multicolor sprinkles, pearl sugar crystals (from beet sugar). The sprinkles and sugar crystals add visible festive texture and a touch of sweetness.
- Decaf Black Cream: Tasting notes: soft cream + vanilla. Ingredients: decaffeinated black tea, vanilla, cream flavor, cornflowers. The cream flavor is dairy-free according to the description, and the blend is positioned as a substitute for English Breakfast with milk and sugar.
Caffeine: both are decaf, not caffeine-free
Both teas are decaffeinated using the CO2 process, which uses naturally occurring CO2 under high pressure and temperature to extract caffeine without chemical solvents. The catalog explicitly states that a very slight residue of caffeine will remain, which is why these are called decaf teas rather than no-caffeine teas. If you are avoiding caffeine entirely—for medical or personal reasons—neither is the right choice; the catalog points to herbal teas, rooibos, honeybush, and fruit tisanes as 100% naturally caffeine-free alternatives.
For most evening drinkers, the trace amount left after CO2 decaffeination is unlikely to be a problem, but the catalog does not quantify it. Treat that as an unknown rather than a guarantee.
Catalog evidence for each blend
-
Mistletoe Tea: Limited-edition blend; 40% off all sizes; available while supplies last. Seasonal availability means Mistletoe Tea is not a year-round staple—stock up if you love it.
Mistletoe Tea
-
Decaf Black Cream: Described as a brisk black tea with subtle soft cream notes; recommended for those who enjoy English Breakfast with milk and sugar. Decaf Black Cream is a consistent everyday option with a familiar profile.
Decaf Black Cream
Steeping: same method, slightly different experience
Both teas share identical steep directions: 1 heaping teaspoon per 8 oz of boiling water (205–212°F) for 3–4 minutes. That makes the brewing routine interchangeable—no need to remember different temperatures or times. The difference is in what you taste: Mistletoe Tea's cinnamon and mint come forward with sweetness from the sprinkles and sugar crystals, while Decaf Black Cream delivers a soft, creamy vanilla note over a brisk black tea base.
Because the steep directions are the same, you can adjust strength by changing the amount of tea or the time within the 3–4 minute window. The catalog does not provide separate recommendations for iced tea or milk additions, so experiment cautiously if you want to serve either over ice.
Sizes and value for your evening habit
Both teas are sold in four sizes: Small 50g (1.8oz), Medium 150g (5.3oz), Large 300g (10.6oz), and XL 454g (16oz). That means you can try a small amount before committing to a larger bag. Mistletoe Tea is currently discounted 40% across all sizes, which makes it an attractive option if you want a festive blend for the holidays. Decaf Black Cream is a regular catalog item, so it is a safer bet for year-round drinking.
Neither product page confirms a shelf life or best-by date, so buy a size you can finish within a few months of opening. If you drink tea daily, the Medium or Large size is likely more economical; for occasional cups, start with Small.
What the catalog does not confirm
The catalog does not state whether either tea is allergen-free, gluten-free, or suitable for specific dietary restrictions. Mistletoe Tea contains chocolate, sprinkles, and pearl sugar crystals, but the catalog does not list sub-ingredients for those components, so check the packaging if you have allergies. Decaf Black Cream contains 'cream flavor' and 'vanilla' without further specification; the description says the cream flavor is dairy-free, but the full ingredient list should be verified on the package.
Neither page provides a caffeine amount per cup, storage instructions after opening, or a definitive answer on whether the teas are kosher or organic. If any of these matter to you, contact the company directly before purchasing.
Which one fits your evening cup?
Choose Mistletoe Tea if you want a festive, limited-edition treat with cinnamon, mint, and a touch of sweetness—and you don't mind that it may sell out. It is best for holiday gatherings or cozy nights when you want something special. Choose Decaf Black Cream if you prefer a smooth, creamy black tea that stands in for your usual English Breakfast, available year-round and versatile with or without milk. Both are decaffeinated with CO2 and contain trace caffeine, so they are not suitable for a strictly caffeine-free diet.




